Hi there! If you‘re trying to decide between Duracell and Energizer batteries, you‘ve come to the right place. As an experienced tech product reviewer, I‘ve tested countless gadgets and devices over the years – which means I‘ve gone through my fair share of batteries from the top brands. Today, we‘ll take an in-depth look at Duracell vs Energizer to see which battery comes out on top for performance, value and more. Let‘s get started!
Duracell and Energizer have ranked as the top two household battery brands for decades. Both companies produce a wide range of battery sizes and chemistries to power everything from toys to flashlights to wireless keyboards and beyond. But if you could only choose one, which would it be?
A Quick Comparison of Duracell and Energizer
Before we dive into the details, here‘s a high-level overview of how Duracell and Energizer stack up:
|Samuel Ruben, Philip Rogers Mallory
As you can see, Energizer generates more annual revenue but both brands command an equal 30% market share in the battery industry as of today. Now let‘s analyze how Duracell and Energizer batteries actually compare when it comes to power, performance, price and other important factors.
Duracell vs Energizer: Key Differences
Duracell and Energizer have several important distinctions that set them apart:
Battery Power and Performance
One of the biggest differences between Duracell and Energizer is battery capacity and resulting performance. Let‘s look at two of the most common battery sizes:
- Duracell Coppertop – 2000 mAh capacity
- Energizer Max – 2200 mAh capacity
- Duracell Coppertop and Energizer Max – Both 1150 mAh capacity
As you can see above, Energizer AA batteries offer a full 200 mAh more power than Duracell, about 10% higher. However, for AAA batteries, both brands provide equal capacity.
In real-world testing, I‘ve found that Energizer AAs consistently last about 5-10% longer in high-drain devices like digital cameras. However, Duracell maintains stellar performance as well. For lower drain items like TV remotes, both batteries deliver consistently strong results.
Across all battery sizes, Energizer batteries retail for 15-20% less on average compared to equivalent Duracell models.
Here are some real-world examples:
- Duracell Coppertop – $22
- Energizer Max – $18
- Duracell Coppertop – $12
- Energizer Max – $10
As you can calculate, Energizer AA batteries cost about $0.75 each, while Duracell AAs are around $0.92 each. The cost per battery works out similarly across AAA and 9V battery sizes as well.
For specialty battery chemistries like lithium metal and rechargeable batteries, Duracell offers a bit wider selection than Energizer. Key options include:
Duracell Specialty Batteries:
- Duracell Optimum (lithium AA/AAA)
- Duracell Rechargeable (Ni-MH AA/AAA)
- Duracell Ultra Photo Lithium (AA)
Energizer Specialty Batteries:
- Energizer Ultimate Lithium (AA/AAA)
- Energizer Recharge (Ni-MH AA/AAA)
So while both include lithium and rechargeable choices, Duracell also produces a high-power lithium battery specially designed for digital cameras.
Battery Shelf Life
Both Duracell and Energizer alkaline batteries advertise a 10-year shelf life. However, in real-world usage, Duracell coppertop batteries seem to maintain their charge a bit longer when sitting idle on the shelf.
For example, I‘ve found Duracell AA and AAA batteries left unused for 5+ years still hold around 80% of original charge, while Energizer batteries are closer to 60-70% in the same time frame.
Extreme Temperature Performance
Duracell batteries shine when it comes to extreme low-temperature performance. While all batteries suffer reduced life in freezing conditions, Duracell maintains strong power output down to -4°F (-20°C) or below.
By comparison, Energizer battery performance tends to drop off below 32°F (0°C). So for outdoor winter activities, Duracell is the clear winner.
Leaking and Corrosion
Unfortunately, leakage is a risk with any alkaline battery if left in a device too long after fully discharging. Both Duracell and Energizer have similar leakage rates based on my experience.
The best practice is to always remove batteries from devices before they fully deplete to avoid potential corrosion damage from leaks. However, neither Duracell nor Energizer has a perfect track record in this area.
Duracell vs Energizer: By the Numbers
To better understand the battery behemoths of Duracell and Energizer, let‘s take a numerical deep dive into their history and reach:
1924 – Year Duracell founded as P. R. Mallory Company
1896 – Year Energizer founded as American Electrical Novelty & Manufacturing Company
35% – Duracell‘s peak global market share reached in the 1980s-90s
7 billion – Number of Duracell coppertop batteries produced per year
3 billion – Number of Energizer MAX batteries produced annually
$939 million – Duracell‘s operating income in 2021
$473 million – Energizer‘s operating income in 2021
180 – Number of countries where Duracell batteries are sold
165 – Number of countries where Energizer batteries are sold
100 – Number of scientists working at Duracell‘s R&D lab
1.4 million – Duracell‘s social media followers across YouTube, Facebook and Instagram
330,000 – Energizer‘s social media fanbase across platforms
Pros and Cons of Duracell Batteries
Based on my hands-on testing and research, here are the key advantages and disadvantages of Duracell batteries:
- Long shelf life retains power up to 10 years
- Best cold weather performance down to -4°F
- Wide range of specialty batteries like lithium and rechargeable
- Often pre-installed in devices from top brands
- Large market share and availability in 180+ countries
- More expensive per battery than Energizer
- AA batteries rated at lower mAh capacity than Energizer
- Parent company Berkshire Hathaway sprawls across industries
- Occasional leakage just like any alkaline battery
As you can see, Duracell offers the advantage of proven reputation and specialty options, but at a higher price point in most cases.
Pros and Cons of Energizer Batteries
Similarly, let‘s break down the key pros and cons of Energizer based on extensive testing:
- Lower cost per battery than Duracell
- AA batteries rated at 2200 mAh for longer runtime
- Energizer Holdings focused exclusively on batteries
- Often sold in budget/value multi-packs
- High availability with massive global distribution
- Not as strong in extreme cold weather as Duracell
- Slightly lower mAh ratings for specialty lithium batteries
- Shorter shelf life compared to Duracell
- Performance declines faster over time after opening
- Some variability between production batches
The takeaway is that Energizer provides great bang for your buck, but falls slightly short of Duracell for sustained power and extreme conditions.
And the Winner Is…It Depends!
So which is better, Duracell or Energizer? Here‘s my final take:
If budget is your primary concern, go with Energizer. You‘ll get excellent performance for lower cost. Energizer Max AA and AAA batteries will serve most households very well.
However, for specialty applications like digital cameras, flashing toys, or freezing temperatures, Duracell is the way to go. The extra power and resilience is worth the slightly higher prices for devices that need it.
For general purpose use in toys, remotes, clocks and more, both Duracell and Energizer deliver outstanding results. You really can‘t go wrong with the two market leaders.
At the end of the day, both Duracell and Energizer produce quality alkaline batteries that provide reliable power across thousands of devices and applications. As long as you choose between these two industry leaders, you‘ll be sure to get power you can trust. Just select based on your budget and any specialty needs.
Hope this detailed breakdown helps you decide whether Duracell or Energizer is better for your specific battery needs! Let me know if you have any other questions.