Skip to content

Google Fi vs. AT&T: What’s the Better Wireless Option?

Choosing the right wireless carrier is one of the most important technology decisions you can make. The provider you pick will determine everything from how reliable your connection is to how much you pay each month. With so many options on the market, it can be tough to decipher which is best for your unique needs.

In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll be comparing two of the top wireless carriers in the U.S.—Google Fi and AT&T. I‘ll be evaluating how these networks stack up across a range of factors, from data coverage and plan pricing to customer satisfaction and 5G availability. My goal is to equip you with the insights you need to determine which carrier is the better fit for you.

By the end of this guide, you‘ll have a clear picture of the key differences between Google Fi and AT&T. Let‘s dive in and start exploring how these two providers compare.

An Overview of Google Fi and AT&T

Before we dig into the nitty gritty details, let‘s briefly introduce these two carriers.

Google Fi first launched in 2015 as an MVNO (mobile virtual network operator). Instead of building their own cell towers, Google Fi piggybacks off of other networks like T-Mobile, Sprint, and U.S. Cellular. Key features include:

  • Pay-as-you-go pricing starting at $20/month
  • Seamless switching between carrier networks
  • Built-in international coverage with over 135 countries supported
  • Strong optimization for Android devices, especially Pixel phones

AT&T is one of the biggest and most established wireless carriers in the U.S. The company operates one of the largest 4G LTE and 5G networks nationwide. Highlights include:

  • A wide range of plan options from prepaid to unlimited data
  • Bundles available for adding TV, internet, and home phone services
  • Extensive selection of supported devices from smartphones to tablets
  • Large assortment of perks like streaming subscriptions and hotspot data

Now that we‘ve introduced both carriers, let‘s take a detailed look at how they compare across 10 key factors.

Network Coverage and Performance

The breadth and quality of a carrier‘s network is paramount. No one wants to deal with slow data speeds or constant dropped connections. In the battle between AT&T vs. Google Fi, which carrier offers the best coverage and performance?

As one of the three major wireless carriers in the U.S., AT&T operates one of the largest and most reliable 4G LTE networks. Their coverage spans over 99% of Americans across the 50 states, even reaching many rural locations. In independent tests by RootMetrics, AT&T tied Verizon for #1 in overall network performance across 125 metropolitan markets. Their median download speed clocked in at 33.1 Mbps, which is excellent for streaming, browsing, and using data-intensive apps.

Google Fi, on the other hand, has to rely on its partner networks of T-Mobile, Sprint, and U.S. Cellular to provide coverage. Since T-Mobile is their primary network, their coverage map looks very similar—not quite as extensive as Verizon or AT&T. In rural testing by PCMag, Google Fi turned up some coverage gaps and inconsistent speeds compared to the major carriers. Their average download speed comes in around 21 Mbps based on OpenSignal data, which is decent but not blazing fast.

So when it comes to widespread coverage and performance, AT&T is the winner. Their robust infrastructure offers the most reliable connections across the country, even in remote areas. Google Fi’s coverage is solid in most suburban and urban zones, but lacks the footprint to match AT&T.

Winner: AT&T

Plan Options and Pricing

Today‘s carriers offer a dizzying array of plans to meet different needs. Next let‘s see how AT&T and Google Fi compare when it comes to plan selection and affordability.

Google Fi runs on a simple pay-as-you-go model. For $20 per month you get unlimited talk and text, plus an additional $10 for each GB of data. There are no contracts or commitment required. Data is prorated, so if you only use 0.5GB one month, you only pay $5. There is also an unlimited plan available for $70 per month.

By comparison, AT&T offers a lot more plan customization. Their unlimited plans range from $35-$50 based on features, but you can also opt for a prepaid plan with just a few GB of data. Shared data is available starting at $50 for two lines and $80 for four lines. Business options are extensive as well. However, keep in mind that pricing for additional lines and features like device insurance can add up quickly.

For light to moderate individual usage, Google Fi is the more affordable option. But AT&T offers more selections for high data users, families, and enterprises. Their bundling options also help you save when you combine mobile with home internet or TV.

So when it comes to plan variety and pricing packages, AT&T wins out. But savvy data misers can save big with Google Fi.

Winner: AT&T

Phone Selection

Today‘s smartphones pack impressive capabilities into sleek, compact designs. When picking a carrier, it‘s important to look at device compatibility. So how do AT&T and Google Fi compare when it comes to supporting popular models?

With Google Fi, phone selection is quite limited—especially if you‘re an iPhone user. Since Fi relies on networks like T-Mobile, only unlocked devices compatible with that network will work. Officially, the service only supports Pixel, Samsung Galaxy, and a handful of Motorola models. There are community workarounds to add support for more devices, but compatibility is not guaranteed.

By contrast, AT&T supports virtually every major flagship device thanks to their massive network—including the latest iPhones, Samsung Galaxy models, LG devices, and more. Switching your existing phone to AT&T‘s network is quick and simple with a SIM card swap. Plus, AT&T frequently offers big discounts of $300 or more on new devices when you switch and add a line.

Clearly AT&T is the winner when it comes to device selection and compatibility. Google Fi works seamlessly with Pixels, but most users will have many more options on AT&T‘s expansive network.

Winner: AT&T

International Coverage

Do you travel overseas often? Then having free or affordable international coverage is a major perk. How do AT&T and Google Fi help you stay connected abroad?

International coverage is a real highlight of Google Fi. You can use talk, text, and LTE data in over 135 countries with no extra roaming charges. Google Fi subscribers simply pay their usual domestic rates while traveling overseas. Speeds are also relatively fast thanks to roaming agreements with local carriers.

AT&T also offers international roaming packages, but with much less flexibility. You can opt to pay $10 per day to access your talk, text, and data in Mexico, Canada, or over 100 other countries. However data rates are exorbitantly expensive at $10 per MB used. Unless you absolutely need cellular access abroad, you‘ll want to rely on WiFi.

For any frequent travelers and globetrotters, Google Fi is by far the better choice. Their seamless international coverage with affordable rates lets you use your phone worry-free worldwide.

Winner: Google Fi

Family Features and Plans

Many households today connect multiple devices and family members on shared plans. Which carrier offers the better multi-line packages and features?

AT&T has long catered to families and multi-line households. Their unlimited plans can be mixed and matched based on each person‘s data needs, with discounts when you add more lines. Mobile hotspot usage is also included so you can conveniently connect tablets and laptops. And bundling AT&T wireless with their home internet or TV services can help families save.

In comparison, Google Fi is not quite as family-friendly. While you can add up to 5 people to your group plan, there are no per-line discounts. Video streaming is also capped at 480p resolution to manage data usage. On the plus side, it‘s easy to share data as needed between devices on Google Fi each month. But the lack of unlimited hotspot data makes it less suitable for households with many devices.

Overall, AT&T offers better flexibility for family plans. Their wide range of data options, mobile hotspot allowances, and bundle discounts provide more value for households.

Winner: AT&T

5G Availability

5G represents the next generation in wireless connectivity. By providing ultra-fast speeds with reduced latency, 5G networks will power new mobile applications in the years ahead. Which carrier currently offers the best 5G coverage and performance?

AT&T has been rapidly expanding their 5G network nationwide over the past two years. As of this writing, their low-band 5G network covers over 250 million people across the U.S. Speeds on their low-band 5G average around 100 Mbps down. In addition, AT&T has started rolling out mmWave-based 5G+ service in 36 cities including New York, Los Angeles, and Dallas. 5G+ can deliver blazing multi-gigabit speeds for the best mobile experience.

Google Fi currently provides 5G access by leveraging T-Mobile‘s nationwide network. Speeds tend to land around 100 Mbps down, on par with AT&T‘s current low-band network. However, Google Fi‘s 5G coverage is less extensive since it relies on T-Mobile. And you won‘t get access to the super-fast, limited-range mmWave 5G+ technology offered by AT&T.

If you want access to the latest and greatest 5G networks rolling out now, AT&T is the leader. Their wide and growing 5G footprint together with 5G+ mmWave deployment keeps them on the cutting edge.

Winner: AT&T

Perks and Extras

Beyond coverage and cost, some users also consider perks and extras when evaluating wireless carriers. Let‘s compare what Google Fi and AT&T toss in to sweeten the deal.

On the Google Fi side, perks are relatively minimal. The service does include free Google One membership for expanded cloud storage with your plan. However, they don‘t offer much else beyond the standard wireless service. One advantage is you can temporarily pause service and switch between plans as needed each month.

AT&T, on the other hand, loves to provide perks and bonuses, especially for their higher-tier unlimited plans. We‘re talking things like:

  • 15GB of mobile hotspot data
  • Free access to HBO Max
  • Free roaming in Mexico and Canada
  • Streaming services like HBO Max and Spotify bundled in at a discount
  • Access to AT&T‘s 30,000+ nationwide WiFi hotspots

For subscribers who want extras bundled into their wireless plan, AT&T has the upper hand. Their variety of perks and add-ons provide great additional value.

Winner: AT&T

Customer Satisfaction and Support

No matter how strong the network, every carrier will inevitably have some dissatisfied customers. When issues arise, the quality of support you receive can greatly shape your experience. So how do AT&T and Google Fi stack up on customer satisfaction?

According to surveys by the ACSI, AT&T consistently earns mediocre satisfaction scores compared to other major carriers. Their 2021 score stands at 73/100—higher than competitors like Sprint but lower than both Verizon (76) and T-Mobile (77). Common complaints involve hidden fees, connection reliability, and poor customer service.

Google Fi actually earns excellent satisfaction marks with an ACSI score of 81/100 in 2021. Their rating has climbed steadily since the service launched. Users praise Google Fi‘s simplicity, affordability, and helpful customer support. Their status as an MVNO keeps their offering streamlined compared to larger incumbents.

When it comes to pleasing customers as a wireless provider, Google Fi appears to be doing a better job than industry stalwart AT&T. Superior support helps Google Fi establish trust and loyalty with subscribers.

Winner: Google Fi

Security and Privacy

With our mobile devices serving as lifelines to social media, banking, email, and more, security is paramount. Next let‘s explore how AT&T and Google Fi compare when it comes to protecting user privacy.

AT&T receives mixed marks regarding privacy and security practices. On the plus side, they offer free spam call monitoring and blocking tools. AT&T also received Class B and Class C grades from the EFF on protecting user data from government requests. However, they have faced criticism for sharing location data with third parties and permitting targeted ads without opt-out.

As a Google service, Fi users rely on Google‘s practices regarding data privacy and protection. Google Fi‘s website highlights how data is encrypted through the physical and wireless layers to prevent snooping. The service also uses VPN technology when connecting to public WiFi for added security. However, some privacy advocates are still wary of the data mining and profiling associated with Google‘s advertising model.

Overall, both AT&T and Google Fi incorporate reasonable security protections for consumers, but both have faced scrutiny over privacy-related concerns in today‘s data economy. Users need to assess their comfort level through their own lens.

Winner: Tie

Bundles and Home Services

Many subscribers appreciate the convenience of bundling TV, home internet, and wireless through a single provider. How do AT&T and Google Fi differ when it comes to bundles?

As a triple play provider, AT&T actively pushes bundles across their services. You can combine wireless plans with AT&T fiber internet, DIRECTV, U-verse TV, and/or AT&T Home Phone. Bundles can offer $10 or more off your monthly bill, so it‘s a popular option for many households. However, be aware you‘ll likely face fees if you ever want to unbundle services down the road.

Google Fi focuses exclusively on wireless cell service—that‘s their sole offering. There are no bundles available for TV, home internet, etc. However, you can bundle Google Fi cell plans with Google One cloud storage subscriptions to save some money each month.

Heavy consumers of home services will find more robust bundling opportunities through AT&T. But Google Fi keeps things simple for mobile-only subscribers.

Winner: AT&T

Google Fi vs. AT&T: Key Takeaways

Now that we‘ve thoroughly compared Google Fi and AT&T‘s networks across 10 major factors, what are the key takeaways?

  • AT&T offers superior nationwide coverage and faster overall speeds
  • Google Fi provides better international roaming value
  • AT&T has more plan options including unlimited data
  • Google Fi offers the best bang for buck for light users
  • AT&T supports the widest range of devices
  • Google Fi users are more satisfied with pricing and customer service
  • AT&T provides more perks and home service bundles
  • Google Fi keeps things simple as a wireless-only provider

As you can see, there are good reasons to choose either carrier. AT&T shines when it comes to robust coverage, unlimited plans, device options, perks, and bundles. But Google Fi wins on flexibility, international use, and customer satisfaction.

The right choice depends entirely on your priorities as a wireless user. Let the insights from this guide point you toward the carrier that best aligns with your needs and preferences. And don‘t forget to take advantage of risk-free trial periods to experience each network firsthand if you‘re undecided between AT&T vs. Google Fi.

Recommendations: Who is Each Carrier Best For?

To close out this comparison guide, let‘s boil things down into simple recommendations on the ideal user for each wireless carrier.

Google Fi is best for:

  • Budget-focused subscribers who use less than 3GB of data per month
  • International travelers who need seamless worldwide connectivity
  • tech-Savvy Android enthusiasts (especially Pixel users)
  • Those seeking lower bills without contracts
  • People who prioritize flexibility and simplicity

AT&T is a better fit for:

  • Data-hungry users who stream video and music constantly
  • Families with multiple devices to connect
  • iPhone devotees who want the latest models
  • People who need bundles for home internet and TV
  • Businesses that require rock-solid nationwide LTE coverage

Armed with these key insights, you now have the information you need to decide whether AT&T or Google Fi is the right wireless carrier for your specific wants and needs. Both networks have strengths and weaknesses that will resonate differently depending on your priorities as a mobile user.

I hope this detailed side-by-side comparison has provided valuable guidance as you evaluate these two provider options. Let me know if you have any other questions!