Skip to content

Has Elon Musk Saved or Destroyed Twitter? The Jury‘s Still Out

Hi there! As you‘ve probably noticed, Elon Musk has taken Twitter on a wild ride since he purchased the company in October 2022 for $44 billion. I‘ll provide an in-depth look at how his changes are impacting the platform. There‘s convincing evidence that Musk has severely damaged Twitter so far. But it‘s also possible he could turn things around and realize his digital town square vision. Let‘s dig into the key developments and what they might mean for Twitter‘s future.

Musk‘s Grand Vision for Twitter – Absolute Free Speech Oasis or Unchecked Toxicity?

Musk has been vocal about his disdain for Twitter‘s old leadership and content moderation policies. He aims to make Twitter an anything-goes platform reflecting his free speech absolutist views. Beyond a digital town square, Musk wants to "defeat the spam bots," make Twitter‘s algorithms more transparent, authenticate all humans, enable long-form tweets, and add other new features.

But so far, the hands-off content policies under Musk have unleashed a flood of racist, antisemitic, and otherwise abusive posts. According to the Center for Countering Digital Hate, use of the N-word jumped by 1,700% in 2022 after Musk‘s takeover. Other slurs have proliferated too.

This table from the Anti-Defamation League shows how hateful speech toward marginalized groups skyrocketed right after Musk acquired Twitter:

Type of Slur Weekly Usage Before Takeover Weekly Usage After Takeover
N-word 1,282 26,228
Anti-gay slurs 595 4,153
Anti-trans slurs 598 5,021

This rampant hate speech has led major advertisers like GM, United Airlines, and others to flee Twitter, imperiling its main revenue source. While Musk promises a content moderation council, it‘s yet to materialize. So for now, his changes seem to have unleashed a wave of toxicity alienating many users.

Advertiser Exodus Threatens Twitter‘s Survival

Here‘s a graph showing Twitter‘s advertising revenue from top brands plummeting by 71% year-over-year in December 2022, according to Pathmatics data:

[insert graph]

Heavy hitters like Audi, Coca-Cola, Merck, Mondelez, and many more have paused ads or slashed budgets. Musk lashed out at brands like Apple for pulling ads, but they‘re spooked by the content moderation uncertainty. This massive revenue drop threatens Twitter‘s financial viability.

Moreover, Musk‘s erratic layoffs and product changes resulted in a talent exodus. Former top employees like Yoel Roth, Esther Crawford, and Robin Wheeler resigned by November 2022. This brain drain jeopardizes Twitter‘s capacity to innovate and turn things around.

Scenarios for Twitter‘s Future Under Musk

So where does Twitter go from here? Here are some potential 2023 scenarios based on how key factors play out:

If ad revenue keeps plummeting: More brands flee over unaddressed hate speech, pushing Twitter‘s finances to the brink. Mass layoffs continue. Bankruptcy possible unless Musk unilaterally stabilizes platform.

If Musk lures advertisers back: He follows through on content moderation council and other guardrails, reassuring brands. Revenue stabilizes, but growth still lags competitors.

If new products succeed: Features like long-form tweets and authenticated accounts gain traction. Engagement increases, Twitter explores subscription models. But still faces ad headwinds.

If employee morale craters further: Remaining talent leaves, crippling product development and innovation. Musk forced to acquire other companies to fill gaps. User experience suffers.

The rollercoaster ride for Twitter is clearly far from over. While Musk‘s changes have undoubtedly wreaked havoc so far, he‘s also shown his ability to rapidly adapt at Tesla and other ventures. For Twitter‘s sake, let‘s hope Musk can pivot to a balanced approach – before it‘s too late.

I‘m eager to hear your thoughts! Do you think Musk will get Twitter on track or drive it into the ground? What changes would you want to see on the platform? Let me know in the comments!