The Comptometer: A Revolutionary Calculating Machine That Transformed Business
The comptometer was the first commercially successful key-driven mechanical calculator and a revolutionary device that transformed bookkeeping, accounting and many other business processes for nearly a century. Its speed, reliability and ease-of-use made it an indispensable fixture of offices across the globe. This is the remarkable story of the comptometer’s invention and evolution.
The Need for Speed: Calculating Before Comptometers
For centuries before comptometers arrived, hand calculation aids like the ancient Roman abacus, Pascaline, and slide rules provided some relief for tedious arithmetic work. But these devices had major drawbacks around complexity, accuracy and lack of speed.
By the 1800s, the growing power of machinery was harnessed for calculating with contraptions like the Arithmometer, Baldwin Calculator and Mercedes-Euklid. However, these calculators relied on cumbersome user interfaces like cranks or dials requiring multiple steps to input and process numbers. They were still painfully slow compared to the almost instantaneous speeds ideal for increasingly data-driven 19th century workplaces.
This dilemma inspired a race to build ever more advanced, efficient calculation machines. Out of that quest, an inventive young American machinist named Dorr Eugene Felt would manifest the breakthrough solution – the comptometer.
Inventing the Comptometer out of a Macaroni Box
The comptometer traces its genesis to 1884 when Dorr Felt was working in a Chicago workshop. Felt carefully observed a wood planning machine adjusting the depth of its cuts via a ratchet feed mechanism.
This intrigued the 22-year old about the possibility of adapting a similar step-by-step approach to create an adding and calculating device that improved on the limitations of existing calculators. At the time, leading calculating machines could process a rate of 5-10 calculations per minute. Felt envisioned a machine capable of handling over 100 per minute.
Felt had already patented a couple smaller inventions. But the audacious calculator he now conceived would be on another scale of complexity and innovation. Lacking resources to build his idea in metal, Felt constructed a makeshift wooden prototype model in 1885 out of rubber bands, meat skewers, staples and even a macaroni box.
This strange contraption did not look like much. But its seemingly crude materials masked an ingenious mechanical system unlike anything before. The “macaroni box” model only performed rudimentary operations. Yet its promise was clear, demonstrating the feasibility of Felt’s revolutionary approach. It would form the basis for the first full-fledged practical metal comptometer built the next year.
For his initial funding, Felt collaborated with his cousin who provided a $800 investment to advance the device toward production. This was soon supplemented by a fortuitous partnership with investor Robert Tarrant who helped form the Felt & Tarrant Manufacturing Company. The first marketed comptometer machines followed quickly in 1887.
Mechanical Marvel: How the Comptometer Works
At its heart, Felt’s comptometer utilized a keyboard and internal mechanical components that were deceptively sophisticated. The system operated via both electrical and mechanical processes to enable game-changing performance advantages.
Keyboard and Key Action
The keyboard was organized into vertical columns spaced closely together, each representing a digit place value from ones to tens of thousands. When a key was pressed, levers inside the machine would move up or down at a speed near instantaneous to the human hand. Springs attached to the levers enabled them to return back to neutral "resting" position immediately when released.
This key action turned a series of registers and gears visible through small output windows atop each column on the comptometer exterior. Users could clearly see numbers entered and resulting calculations displayed mechanically before their eyes.
Mechanical Internals
Inside the comptometer, each key press set into motion a precisely engineered mechanical process:
- The keyboard lever arm descended proportional to the digit value
- This engaged a tooth rack turning an output pinion gear and drive pawl
- Interlocked accumulator gears rotated number wheels visible in the output windows
- Carry and borrow mechanisms enabled cascading multi-digit calculations
- A detent prevented reverse motion ensuring unidirectional operation
The elegance was that depressing keys corresponding to digits drove the calculation automatically through the mechanics synchronously designed to achieve astonishing speed and accuracy.
Duplex Capability
Unique features of this system included its speed exceeding 100 operations per minute and that multiple keys across columns could be pressed down simultaneously. This “duplex capability” dramatically enhanced usability for multiplication/division and other business calculations requiring entering multi-digit numbers in one motion.
Controlled Key
Later comptometer models incorporated additional innovations like the “controlled key system” – locks preventing the machine from operating unless keys were fully depressed properly. This avoided errors from partial keystrokes that could otherwise sneak through undetected.
Together these capabilities ushered a revolutionary advance in mechanical calculation utility and reliability.
Early Comptometer Models
From Felt’s first practical metal comptometer prototype in 1886, the devices quickly gained exposure and commercial success. Key milestones included:
-
1887 – Felt partners with investor Robert Tarrant to form the Felt & Tarrant Mfg Company, selling first production models
-
1903 – Upgraded “Model A” is first comptometer enclosed in a metal case instead of wood
-
1914 – Model F incorporates the breakthrough “controlled key system” to prevent errors
-
1926 – Model J debuts updated aesthetics like green-colored keys instead of traditional black
By 1930, over 140,000 comptometers had been produced and sold primarily across the United States. But global demand was also rising rapidly.
Evolution continued through the 1930‘s with motorized electric models and updated styling. But the core mechanical functionality remained essentially the same for over 50 years proving the durability of Felt‘s original clever design.
profiling key figures
Dorr Eugene Felt (1862-1930)
The inventor of the comptometer, Dorr Felt was born in 1862 in Ohio to parents of modest means. Showing early mechanical aptitude, Felt trained as a machinist before working in railway shops and later Chicago workshops where he conceived the comptometer.
Possessing little formal education, Felt nevertheless exhibited instinctive genius deciphering the flaws of existing calculators and devising an entirely new computing instrument. With an inventor’s relentless focus, Felt built the first comptometer prototype literally using materials like a macaroni box readily on hand.
Felt received multiple patents around applications of his new calculating machine. He reinvested profits continuously improving the comptometer’s capabilities with innovations like the duplex system, comptograph printer and more. While business demands meant Felt sold controlling interest in his firm, he remained actively involved guiding its growth into the 20th century dawn of the computing age he helped usher in.
Robert Tarrant (1844-1920)
A native of Illinois, Robert Tarrant gained experience operating and building grain mills and machine shops before chance brought him into Dorr Felt’s orbit.
In 1886, Tarrant’s Chicago foundry foreman was impressed by a grain elevator mechanism Felt invented and offered workspace for him to develop devices. This connection soon led to Tarrant meeting Felt himself and glimpsing the promising calculator he was devising.
Intrigued by the potential, Tarrant provided funding for Felt to complete an initial run of market-ready machines. This vote of confidence came at a pivotal moment just as the ambitious invention was advancing from idea to reality. Soon Tarrant and Felt formally partnered launching the company bearing their names that revolutionized offices worldwide.
While less famous than his partner, Tarrant was the archetype of 19th century American industrialists whose capital investment and operational expertise combined with inventor innovation to power economic growth.
Business Impact
The comptometer arrived at an opportune time just as American rail, mining, manufacturing and other industries were rapidly expanding. Early adopters included the railroads and financial houses.
Businesses needed to track finances, production, inventory and more. But existing mechanical or human calculation methods were totally inadequate for this mounting workload. clerks labored tediously transcribing rows of figures by hand using pen and paper. The speed, reliability and ease-of-use of Felt‘s invention provided a superior solution.
By 1900, over 35,000 comptometers were already in use displacing manual bookkeeping and crude calculators. Adoption accelerated further as the "modern office" practices emerging in the 1920s relied heavily on advanced business machines. Comptometers were quickly adopted by accounting, banking, government, shipping and warehousing firms. They became ubiquitous in virtually every sphere of business by the early 20th century.
Typing on a comptometer even became a common administrative job. ”Comptometer operator” was a formal occupation and women in particular were heavily recruited to operate the devices. Comptometer speed and efficiency contests also gained popularity as office workers competed demonstrating their arithmetic dexterity.
Invention Gallery: Models, Features & Capabilities
While the core mechanics stayed consistent, comptometer models continually evolved capabilities over decades expanding usefulness for business needs of the era like currency conversions and special functions.
Early Wood Case Model (1903)
The earliest comptometers had a simple box aesthetic with wooden cases modeled on the homemade macaroni box origins.
Streamline Model J (1926)
This popular model introduced stylistic updates like colored green/black keys still evoking classic calculating cash registers.
Comptometer with Sterling Pounds Converter (1950)
Special models supported British pounds currency and decimal tracking crucial for international trade.
Duplex Model (1904)
The duplex feature enabling entering digits in groups dramatically boosted speed.
Model K Electric Motor Drive (1934)
A motorized variant increased automation reducing operator labor.
Continuing Inventions
While best remembered for his signature comptometer, Dorr Felt contributed other consequential innovations advancing mechanical computing technology:
Comptograph Printing Calculator
This 1889 Felt device connected to a comptometer enabling printed output of calculations onto paper. The comptograph was an early precursor to moder computing peripherals like printers and data storage devices. It also foreshadowed computing applicability for data reporting needs.
Duplex System
Allowing simultaneous multiple key presses greatly enhanced manual calculation efficiency. The duplex system was Felt’s brainchild first introduced in 1904 providing a 5X speed boost.
Controlled Key
Preventing incorrect incomplete keystrokes was another Felt breakthrough improving comptometer performance and accuracy.
The Digital Age Dawns
By the 1970s, electronic calculators and computers began displacing comptometers after nearly a century of dominance. The rapid pace of digital advancement with integrated circuits and programming rendered mechanical systems obsolete.
But the comptometer had stood the test of time and brought computational abilities to business and society on an unprecedented scale.
The comptometer ushered in a transformation in efficiency and productivity that supported rising modern economies. And it was a crucial step in the inevitable progression towards the computer age that shapes offices and commerce worldwide today. Dorr Felt’s computing creation built from a macaroni box ended up changing the world.
