So you‘re looking to upgrade to a smart display and want to know – should I get the Amazon Echo Show or the Google Nest Hub? I‘ve done the research to compare the two, and I‘m here to help you decide!
I know how tough it can be to choose between these popular smart home devices. Both the Echo Show and Nest Hub offer advanced voice assistants, media streaming, home automation control and more. But there are some key differences that set them apart.
In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll compare the Echo Show and Nest Hub across 10 different categories. I‘ll provide detailed analysis so you can determine the right option for your needs. Let‘s dive in!
Display Face-Off: Echo Show vs. Nest Hub
One of the main functions of any smart display is…well…the display! Picture quality, size and resolution determine how enjoyable the experience will be.
The Echo Show wins this round with higher resolution screens across all models:
- Echo Show 5: 960 x 480 pixels
- Echo Show 8: 1280 x 800 pixels
- Echo Show 10: 1920 x 1080 pixels
Comparatively, the Nest Hub displays offer:
- Nest Hub: 1024 x 600 pixels
- Nest Hub Max: 1280 x 800 pixels
According to Consumer Reports testing, the Echo Show 8 matched top-rated tablets in color accuracy, hue saturation, and visual sharpness. The Nest Hub Max also performed well, but its larger size doesn’t increase resolution.
Bottom line – with an HD or Full HD display on all variants, the Echo Show provides a crisper, more vivid viewing experience. But both are excellent for streaming videos and engaging visuals.
Audio Showdown: Nest Hub vs. Echo Show
Audio quality is crucial if you‘ll be listening to music, podcasts or calls on your smart display. Let‘s compare the sound components.
The standard Nest Hub packs a powerful speaker in its compact body. The woofer and tweeter deliver surprisingly robust bass, mids, and highs that fills rooms with booming sound.
Comparatively, the small Echo Show 5 and 8 only have dual 2” speakers that are just okay. To match the Nest Hub’s audio performance, you need to upgrade to the premium Echo Show 10 with dual 1" tweeters and a 3” woofer.
So when it comes to audio, the affordable Nest Hub holds its own against the Echo Show lineup. Unless you spring for the pricier Echo Show 10, the Nest Hub provides a better audio experience overall.
Voice Assistant Showdown: Alexa vs. Google Assistant
The built-in voice assistant is integral to what your smart display can do. This pits Amazon‘s Alexa against the Google Assistant. Let‘s see how their capabilities compare.
Alexa has improved significantly over the years. It can now handle general knowledge questions, shopping tasks, and smart home commands pretty well. Tens of thousands of Alexa "Skills" (like apps) allow you to summon an Uber, play games, check your security cameras and more.
But Google Assistant is more intelligent, understanding context and conversational queries better thanks to Google‘s vast Knowledge Graph database. It also delivers tighter integration with Google services like search, maps, and photos.
So if you primarily want a voice assistant that understands natural speech and answers questions accurately, Google Assistant is superior. But Alexa users won‘t be disappointed either – both perform well for most smart home and entertainment requests.
Smart Home Showdown: Echo vs. Nest for Device Control
A core function of any smart display is controlling other connected devices like lights, switches and appliances. Here‘s how the Echo Show and Nest Hub compare for smart home management.
The Echo Show seamlessly connects with Alexa-compatible devices. Through the Alexa app, you can easily set up and control thousands of Works with Alexa gadgets like smart bulbs, plugs, cameras and more.
Likewise, the Nest Hub leverages Google Assistant for robust integration with Google/Nest products along with 30,000+ supported third-party devices. The Google Home app also makes connecting and managing gadgets a breeze.
No matter which ecosystem you choose, you‘ll have no shortage of options to create an automated, voice-controlled home. Both Amazon and Google support expansive product catalogs spanning every smart home category imaginable.
Streaming Showdown: Media & Entertainment
A prime activity for any smart display is streaming shows, movies, music and more. Let‘s compare how the Echo Show and Nest Hub stack up for entertainment.
The Echo Show offers full integration with Amazon‘s services like Prime Video and Amazon Music. You also get apps for major platforms like Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, HBO Max and Spotify. Controls are easy with touchscreen or the included remote.
The Nest Hub also provides apps for these popular streaming services. Unique benefits include native YouTube support, Chromecast streaming capabilities, and tight integration with Google Photos.
Both give you access to all the top media options. It‘s a matter of whether you prefer Amazon or Google‘s ecosystems and services. For example, YouTube fans may prefer the Nest Hub. But the Echo Show is great if you want to cast shows from FireTV devices or listen to music on Amazon Music.
Video Calling Showdown: Echo Show vs Nest Hub Max
Smart displays can function as video chat hubs. But among these devices, only select models offer camera support for video calls.
The Echo Show 5, 8 and 10 all contain front-facing cameras. You can make video calls to anyone with the Alexa app, Echo device, or Skype. The built-in auto-framing keeps you centered in the shot.
Meanwhile, only the high-end Nest Hub Max has a camera, so it‘s the sole model that can handle video calling. The 6.5MP sensor enables crisp 1080p Google Duo video chats. The ultrawide field of view and auto zoom/framing make calls easy and optimal.
For video calls, the Nest Hub Max wins out with fantastic video quality and a wider, smarter camera. But the Echo Show line offers the flexibility of video chatting on any model – not just the most premium variant.
Photo Showdown: Displaying Your Memories
One of the most delightful uses for smart displays is showcasing favorite photos and memories. How do the Echo Show and Nest Hub compare for visual reminiscence?
On the Echo Show, you simply upload your photos through Amazon Photos on the web, mobile app or desktop software. Your pics then display beautifully on the Echo Show‘s top-notch screens. It‘s like a digital photo frame, only voice activated!
The Nest Hub also beautifully highlights your cherished photos, thanks to native integration with Google Photos. All pics and albums stored in your Google account automatically populate the Nest Hub. Curated features like Live Albums and slideshows make your memories shine.
Both do an excellent job at photo display thanks to tight cloud storage integrations. So it comes down to whether you want the unlimited storage and facial recognition of Google Photos, or the unlimited full-resolution backup of Amazon Photos.
Privacy Showdown: Echo vs. Nest Data Protection
With an internet-connected camera and microphone on these devices, privacy is paramount. Let‘s explore how the Echo Show and Nest Hub safeguard your personal data.
On all Echo Show models, the camera shutter and microphone mute buttons give you physical control over the sensors. In the Alexa app, you can also view/delete recordings, enable deletion requests, and turn off motion tracking.
The Nest Hub‘s only physical control is the mic toggle switch disconnecting power to the mics. In the Home app, you can enable features like Web & App Activity linking and camera event sharing. But overall, privacy settings are more limited compared to Alexa.
So Amazon gives you more robust tools to customize Echo Show data collection and visibility based on your comfort level. However, both Google and Amazon share information on how they use, store and secure your personal data in their online privacy hubs.
Design Showdown: Echo vs. Nest Aesthetics
While minor, the aesthetics and form factor of a smart display can impact your enjoyment having it visible in your living space.
The Echo Show devices have an understated, minimalist look with thin symmetrical bezels keeping focus on the display. They come in neutral white and black color options. Wall mounting capabilities maintain a clean appearance.
Meanwhile, the Nest Hub sports a soft, rounded design covered in homey fabric available in a handful of muted colors like chalk and charcoal. The auto-adjusting display minimizes visual distractions.
Both blend in nicely with modern decor. So your choice comes down to whether you prefer the sleek simplicity of the Echo Show, or the warm, approachable look and feel of the Nest Hub.
Special Features Showdown
Let‘s compare some extra special features you only get with one model or the other:
Echo Show Perks
- Alexa Guard – Detects alarms and smoke while you‘re away
- Telepresence – Remotely drop-in to check your home
- Visual ID – Recognizes you to provide personalized results
Nest Hub Exclusives
- Sleep Tracking – Monitors your sleep habits if kept on your nightstand
- Quick Gestures – Tap and hold the screen to pause media
- Sunrise Alarm – Brightens the screen gradually to wake you up
These unique functions add even more handy capabilities to each smart display experience. Factor them in when deciding which additional features matter most to you.
Value Showdown: Echo vs. Nest Price Considerations
Let‘s compare the pricing and overall value you get between the Echo Show versus the Nest Hub models:
Echo Show Prices
- Echo Show 5: $84.99
- Echo Show 8: $129.99
- Echo Show 10: $249.99
Nest Hub Cost
- Nest Hub: $99
- Nest Hub Max: $229
Given the excellent displays, extensive features, and deep smart home integrations, Echo Show devices provide stellar value. But the Nest Hub lineup also packs in mighty performance and functionality at reasonable prices.
So while the Echo Show gives you more display for your dollar, the Nest Hub counters with bigger audio and premium video calling absent from the lower-end Echo models. Both offer outstanding overall value.
The Final Showdown: Which Should You Buy?
So what‘s the final verdict? Should you buy the Amazon Echo Show or the Google Nest Hub?
Honestly, you can‘t go wrong with either of these awesome smart displays. Both provide helper voice assistants, robust smart home control, endless entertainment options and visual appeal.
But here are a few tips that may help you decide:
-
If you want more screen real estate, better photo viewing, and video calling across all models – go with the Echo Show.
-
If audio quality, intelligence of the assistant, and deeper Google ecosystem integration are priorities – choose the Nest Hub.
-
Evaluate which voice assistant (Alexa or Google) you‘re more comfortable with. And which ecosystems for music, movies, and more you already use.
-
Consider the style and extra features that are personally important to you. Do you want a sleek stance (Echo) or homey fabric design (Nest)?
At the end of the day, it comes down to your specific needs and preferences. Hopefully this comprehensive feature comparison gave you the insights you need to decide on the best smart display for your home!
Let me know if you have any other questions. I‘m happy to chat more about the Echo Show vs. Nest Hub to help you pick the perfect smart companion.
