Skip to content

HTC Vive vs. PlayStation VR2: Which VR Headset Reigns Supreme?

Virtual reality has come a long way since the early days of blurry, low-res displays and limited tracking. Today, consumers have their pick of several high-end VR headsets that deliver increasingly immersive and graphically rich experiences. Two of the major players in this space are HTC with its Vive series and Sony with the upcoming PlayStation VR2.

Both companies are no stranger to VR. HTC has been a pioneer in the arena since the original Vive launched in 2016, while Sony found success with the PSVR headset for PS4, which sold over 5 million units according to a Sony earnings report. Now, they‘re going head-to-head once again to capture the next generation of VR gamers.

As a digital technology expert with years of experience covering VR, I‘ve had the chance to extensively test both platforms. In this in-depth comparison, I‘ll break down the key differences between the HTC Vive and PlayStation VR2 across essential categories like specs, performance, content, comfort, and price. By the end, you‘ll have a clear idea of which headset is the right fit for your VR needs and budget.

Specs Showdown

Let‘s start with the raw numbers. Here‘s how the HTC Vive Pro 2 (HTC‘s current flagship consumer headset) and the PlayStation VR2 stack up:

Spec HTC Vive Pro 2 PlayStation VR2
Display Dual RGB low persistence LCD OLED
Resolution 2448×2448 per eye 2000×2040 per eye
Refresh Rate 120Hz 90Hz, 120Hz
Field of View Up to 120 degrees Approx. 110 degrees
Audio Hi-res certified headphones Stereo headphone jack
Tracking SteamVR 2.0 base stations Inside-out (4 cameras)
Connection Wired (DisplayPort 1.2) Wired (USB-C)
Weight 850g <600g

The Vive Pro 2 has the edge in pure resolution, but the PSVR2‘s OLED display should provide superior contrast and color reproduction. The field of view difference is minimal. Notably, the PSVR2 uses inside-out tracking, which eliminates the need for external sensors. However, this approach can be less precise than SteamVR‘s base stations.

Another key difference is the refresh rate. The Vive Pro 2 can hit 120Hz consistently, while the PSVR2 will likely use 90Hz for most titles and reserve 120Hz for less graphically intensive games and apps.

Weight is also a factor, with the PSVR2 coming in significantly lighter at under 600g compared to the Vive Pro 2‘s heftier 850g chassis. This could make the PSVR2 more comfortable for longer play sessions.

It‘s worth noting that HTC does offer an even higher-end headset in the Vive Pro Eye, which includes eye tracking. This matches a key feature of the PSVR2. Eye tracking enables foveated rendering, which concentrates graphical detail on where the user is looking to boost performance.

Platforms and Performance

Raw specs only tell part of the story when it comes to VR headset performance. A critical factor is the hardware platform powering the headset.

The HTC Vive line primarily relies on a PC to drive VR experiences (with the exception of the standalone Vive Focus 3). To get the most out of a Vive headset, you‘ll need a fairly beefy gaming rig. HTC recommends at least an Intel Core i5-4590 or AMD FX 8350 CPU, NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 or AMD Radeon RX 480 GPU, and 4GB of RAM.

In practice, those are bare minimum specs for decent VR performance. For demanding VR titles, you‘ll want an even more powerful machine. A 2020 Steam hardware survey shows that the majority of VR users on Steam have systems with NVIDIA GeForce RTX 20 and 30 series GPUs.

The PlayStation VR2, on the other hand, is designed solely for the PlayStation 5 console. This means that every PSVR2 owner will have an identical baseline of hardware powering their VR setup. For developers, this close coupling of hardware and software allows for greater optimization and the ability to push the PSVR2 to its limits.

The PS5 is a very capable gaming machine, with a custom 8-core AMD Zen 2 CPU, 10.3 teraflop AMD RDNA 2 GPU, and 16GB of GDDR6 RAM. It also features an ultra-high speed SSD that can load games and assets extremely quickly.

While we have yet to see any PSVR2 titles running on final hardware, I expect the headset to deliver graphics on par or even exceeding what‘s possible with a Vive Pro 2 connected to a high-end PC. The key advantage is that every PSVR2 game will be tuned for a specific hardware target.

Of course, the major caveat is that you need to own a PS5 to use the PSVR2, which is still a challenge given ongoing supply constraints. The Vive line offers more flexibility since it can work with a wide range of PC configurations.

Content: Exclusives and Ecosystems

Compelling content is what ultimately sells VR headsets. Both HTC Vive and PlayStation VR have established ecosystems with a range of games and apps.

Vive headsets have access to the extensive Steam VR library. Popular titles like Half-Life: Alyx, Star Wars: Squadrons, and Superhot VR are all playable on Vive. You can also find a number of excellent Vive exclusives such as Moss, Pixel Ripped 1995, and Westworld Awakening.

HTC runs its own VR app store called Viveport, which offers hundreds of titles. The $12.99 per month Viveport Infinity subscription provides unlimited access to a good chunk of this library. Overall, the Vive has an edge in sheer quantity of games and apps.

Where PlayStation VR really shines is with high-quality exclusives that leverage the power of narratively-driven, big-budget gaming franchises. Astro Bot Rescue Mission is a masterclass in how to create a VR platformer, while Blood & Truth delivers a cinematic shooter campaign with serious production value.

The PSVR2 looks to continue this trend of must-play exclusives. Horizon Call of the Mountain from Guerrilla Games and Firesprite is being built from the ground up for the new headset. Resident Evil Village is also getting a full PSVR2 version that will support the headset‘s new Sense controllers.

According to a GamesIndustry.biz interview with PlayStation CEO Jim Ryan, there are currently more than 20 games in development for PSVR2. Expect a mix of first-party exclusives and ports of popular VR titles.

It‘s worth noting that the PSVR2 will not be backwards compatible with original PSVR games, so the launch library could be slim. However, Sony has proven adept at courting top developers to create bespoke VR content for its platform.

Comfort and Immersion

A VR headset can have the best specs and games in the world, but it won‘t matter if it‘s uncomfortable to wear for more than 30 minutes at a time. Both HTC and PlayStation have made strides in improving ergonomics and user comfort with their latest headsets.

The PSVR2 looks to be a major upgrade from the original PSVR in terms of comfort and fit. The new headset is slimmer and lighter, with a lens adjustment dial, ventilation system, and a quick-release button for the headband.

Eye tracking and headset haptics are two areas where the PSVR2 could pull ahead in immersion. Eye tracking allows for more intuitive menu navigation and adds an extra layer of realism to social interactions in VR. The headset‘s haptic motors can provide subtle vibrations to enhance sensations like the rumble of an explosion or the feeling of an object whizzing past your head.

The Vive Pro 2 has its strengths in comfort too. The headset features an adjustable head strap, balanced weight distribution, and fine-grained IPD adjustment. HTC also sells a variety of face cushions to customize fit. However, the bulky headstrap and 850g weight can still cause neck strain over time.

Both headsets come with redesigned motion controllers. The PSVR2 Sense controllers are a huge step up from the PS Move wands, with precise tracking, adaptive triggers, and haptic feedback. The Vive wands have seen more iterative improvements in ergonomics and tracking accuracy.

Ultimately, comfort will vary from person to person depending on face shape, head size, and personal preference. The PSVR2 may have a slight edge thanks to its lighter weight and sleeker design, but both headsets offer a far more pleasant experience than earlier VR headsets.

Pricing and Value

There‘s no getting around the fact that high-end VR is still an expensive hobby. The full Vive Pro 2 kit, which includes the headset, two base stations, and controllers, costs a whopping $1399. The headset alone is $799 if you already have base stations and controllers.

The PSVR2‘s pricing is yet to be announced, but I expect it to be in the $400-$500 range based on the original PSVR‘s launch price. That‘s on top of the $500 cost of a PS5 console. All told, a complete PSVR2 setup could run you close to $1000.

So which headset offers the better value? It really depends on your existing hardware and budget. If you already have a PS5, the PSVR2 will likely be the most affordable way to jump into premium VR gaming. You‘ll also benefit from a tightly curated selection of games that will all be optimized for the hardware.

If you‘re a PC gamer with a powerful rig, the HTC Vive line gives you more options at various price points. The Vive Cosmos is a solid entry-level option at $699, while the Pro 2 caters to enthusiasts who want the best of the best and don‘t mind the high price tag. You‘ll also have access to the broadest selection of games and apps through Steam VR and Viveport.

It‘s also worth considering the total cost of ownership. With a PS5 and PSVR2, you‘re locked into a walled garden controlled by Sony. If a new, more advanced console comes out in a few years, you may need to upgrade to access the latest VR content.

With a SteamVR setup, you have full control over your PC and can upgrade individual components as needed. Many Vive games also support cross-buy with Oculus headsets, so your VR library can come with you if you decide to switch to a different PC VR headset in the future.

Conclusion

Deciding between the HTC Vive and PlayStation VR2 ultimately comes down to your priorities and existing hardware setup. If you already own a PS5 and want access to high-quality exclusives, the PSVR2 is shaping up to be an excellent choice. You‘ll enjoy some of the most graphically advanced and comfortable VR experiences available.

If you‘re a PC gamer who wants the widest selection of games and the ability to customize your VR setup, the HTC Vive line is hard to beat. The Vive Pro 2 and Cosmos offer solid performance and visuals, though you‘ll need a beefy PC to get the most out of them.

Looking ahead, both platforms have exciting developments on the horizon. HTC continues to push the envelope with its high-end headsets, and we could see a wireless Vive Pro in the near future. PlayStation is investing heavily in made-for-VR exclusives that could redefine AAA gaming.

As a VR enthusiast, I‘m thrilled to see healthy competition between HTC and PlayStation in the high-end headset market. It‘s a rising tide that lifts all boats, as the saying goes. No matter which headset you choose, it‘s a great time to be a VR gamer. Just be prepared for some serious sticker shock.