The Tesla Model Y has enjoyed immense popularity as one of the first widely available electric crossover SUVs on the market. However, as more automakers join the EV revolution, there are now several compelling alternatives to the Model Y worth considering.
Why Look Beyond the Tesla Model Y?
While the Tesla Model Y remains one of the top selling EVs, there are some factors that may have buyers looking at alternatives:
- Quality control issues – Tesla has faced persistent reports of build quality problems like poor paint, panel gaps and hardware issues. This has hurt their reputation.
- High demand, long waits – With intense demand, buyers can face 6+ month waits to take delivery of a new Model Y. Alternatives may offer faster fulfillment.
- Stale design – Aside from some minor tweaks, the Model Y design has remained largely unchanged since 2019. Alternatives often feature more inspiring or modern styling.
- Tech preferences – Some buyers may prefer a different infotainment system over Tesla‘s spartan touchscreen-only interface.
- Brand experience – Alternatives from luxury brands like Audi and Mercedes-Benz offer different ownership experiences compared to Tesla.
Fortunately, the growing EV marketplace has yielded several excellent alternatives to the Model Y that are definitely worth test driving. Here are 7 of the best options available today.
Volkswagen ID.4
The Volkswagen ID.4 is arguably the most direct competitor to the Tesla Model Y as an affordable electric crossover SUV.
Pricing
The ID.4 starts at $37,495 for the base Pro model, coming in several thousand dollars cheaper than the Model Y. Even the top-trim ID.4 is priced competitively with the entry level Model Y.
Range and Charging
The ID.4 offers between 208-275 miles of range depending on trim level. This comes up short compared to the Model Y‘s up to 330 mile range. Charging capability of 125 kW is solid but can‘t match the Tesla Supercharger network for speed and convenience.
Performance
Performance is a clear advantage for the Model Y over the ID.4. Tesla‘s superior torque and acceleration leaves the ID.4 in the dust. The ID.4 also weighs several hundred pounds more than the Model Y.
Design
Exterior styling of the ID.4 is futuristic yet understated. Interior design is clean and minimalist. The Model Y features a more space-age style that stands out more, for better or worse.
Interior and Tech
The ID.4 interior provides a much warmer, more familiar environment versus the Model Y‘s austere aesthetic. The intuitive touch controls and digital cockpit keep things modern. Active driver aids and over-the-air updates provide cutting-edge convenience and safety.
Summary
For shoppers who prioritize value and a more refined ownership experience, the Volkswagen ID.4 represents an outstanding electric crossover option without the Tesla premium.
Hyundai Ioniq 5
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 combines forward-thinking style with excellent range and performance.
Pricing
The Ioniq 5 has an entry price around $10,000 less than the base Model Y. Even when comparably equipped, the Ioniq 5 maintains a significant value advantage.
Range and Charging
Thanks to its large 77.4 kWh battery, the Ioniq 5 can achieve up to 303 miles per charge which beats out the Model Y. With support for ultra-fast 800V charging, it can add over 200 miles of range in just 15 minutes.
Performance
The single motor Ioniq 5 is peppy, but can‘t match the Tesla‘s breakneck acceleration. The upcoming dual motor performance model aims to compete more directly with a sub-5 second 0-60 mph time.
Design
The Ioniq 5 sports a rad retro-futuristic design unlike anything else on the road. The Model Y has more of a generic crossover shape in comparison.
Interior and Tech
The minimalist cabin of the Ioniq 5 is brightened by eco-friendly materials. Dual 12" screens provide an ultra-wide digital display. Smart tech like phone-as-key, V2L power sharing and OTA updates give it a leg up over the Model Y.
Summary
With its head-turning style, 300+ mile range and lower cost of entry, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 is undoubtedly one of the most appealing electric crossovers available today.
Kia EV6
Closely related to the Ioniq 5, the Kia EV6 delivers stunning performance and tech.
Pricing
The Kia EV6 has base models starting under $50,000. Fully loaded versions still come in below $60,000, giving it a sizable price advantage over the Model Y.
Range and Charging
The maximum 310 mile range beats out every Model Y variant. Ultra-fast 800V charging can restore 210+ miles of range in just 18 minutes – a huge convenience benefit.
Performance
The high-output GT model rips from 0-60 mph in a blistering 3.4 seconds – even quicker than the Model Y Performance. It demonstrates the true performance potential of the EV6.
Design
Like the Ioniq 5, the EV6 turns heads with its bold, futuristic design. The sporty GT-Line model further accentuates this aggressive, cutting-edge styling.
Interior and Tech
Inside the EV6 you‘ll find the same excellent infotainment system and modern tech as the Ioniq 5, including vehicle-to-load power sharing. Active safety assists make driving easy and accident-avoidance simple.
Summary
With supercar-beating acceleration, 310+ mile range, 800V fast charging and competitive pricing, the Kia EV6 gives the Model Y a run for its money. The 5 year/60,000 mile basic and 10 year/100,000 mile powertrain warranties provide peace of mind.
Ford Mustang Mach-E
The Mustang Mach-E adds sporting charisma to the electric SUV formula.
Pricing
With a starting MSRP around $43,000, the Mach-E slightly undercuts the cost of entry for the Model Y. The price difference narrows at higher trim levels.
Range and Charging
Estimates show between 224-312 miles of range based on trim, coming up a bit shy of the Model Y‘s max range. Access to the large Ford charging network mitigates some of the gap versus Tesla Superchargers.
Performance
Acceleration and handling dynamics of the Mach-E are sporty and engaging, although the Model Y‘s instant torque still edges it out in raw speed. The GT Performance Edition Mach-E packs up to 600 hp for serious speed.
Design
The Mustang-inspired styling gives the Mach-E major curb appeal over the Tesla‘s conservative shape. It‘s animated by iconic Mustang design cues adapted for the electric era.
Interior and Tech
The Tech-inspired interior of the Mach-E has flair the Model Y lacks. The ginormous 15.5" touchscreen makes the Tesla‘s display look small, and SYNC 4A keeps it deeply integrated. Active safety aids round out the tech suite.
Summary
The Mustang Mach-E convincingly combines the fun-to-drive qualities of its namesake with leading edge EV capability. Ford fans will feel right at home.
Mercedes EQB
The Mercedes EQB brings trademark luxury and refinement to the electric crossover segment.
Pricing
The EQB starts around $55,000, with the model topping out over $60,000. The premium over Tesla is typical for the greater craftsmanship and prestige of Mercedes-Benz.
Range and Charging
At its max, the EQB offers 245 miles of range – adequate for commuting but well behind the Model Y. Fast charging support is also relatively limited compared to Tesla‘s network.
Performance
Performance priorities clearly favor the Model Y and its radically quick acceleration. The EQB instead prioritizes sublime ride quality and luxurious cruising.
Design
Mercedes imbues the EQB with typical understated elegance and refinement inside and out. The Model Y is the more adventurous of the two designs.
Interior and Tech
Inside the EQB you‘ll be treated to the finest leather, real metal and wood accents and displays flowing seamlessly into the dash. Superior voice controls and active safety tech continue Mercedes‘ innovative tradition.
Summary
For shoppers seeking the utmost luxury driving experience the Mercedes EQB handsomely delivers. The aura of prestige and craftsmanship are clear benefits over the Model Y.
Audi Q4 e-tron
The Q4 e-tron is Audi‘s entry into the premium electric crossover segment.
Pricing
Base models of the Q4 e-tron start around $45,000. Fully equipped models reach upward of $60,000, keeping it cost competitive with the Model Y.
Range and Charging
The maximum 265 mile range trails behind Long Range and Performance variants of the Model Y. Fast charging for the e-tron reaches 125 kW, and access to Electrify America‘s network is included.
Performance
With a gently tuned suspension and modest power output, the e-tron prioritizes comfortable cruising over brisk acceleration. The Model Y provides a much livelier driving feel.
Design
Slick, aerodynamic sheetmetal gives the e-tron a nicely modern look, although not quite as daring as the Model Y. The interior blends technology and hand-crafted materials for a refined environment.
Interior and Tech
Inside you‘ll find Audi‘s acclaimed 12" Virtual Cockpit and heads up display with augmented reality, complemented by the latest active safety assists. Over-the-air updates keep things fresh.
Summary
Sharp handling and cushy cabin make the Audi e-tron a satisfying premium crossover. It lacks the raw performance appeal of the Model Y but compensates with sophistication and tech.
Volvo C40 Recharge
Volvo‘s first electric-only crossover SUV impresses with style, luxury and safety.
Pricing
The C40 starts around $58,000, putting it at a premium over the base Model Y but consistent with other luxury EVs. Higher end models push toward $70,000 fully equipped.
Range and Charging
EPA estimated range sits at 226 miles, which is below average for the segment. Fast charging capability is also middling relative to Tesla and others.
Performance
With just a single motor and muted acceleration, the C40 won‘t stir your senses like the Model Y. Instead it focuses on refined ride and handling balance.
Design
The vibrant color options and fastback shape of the C40 give it a sportier, more emotional look compared to the Model Y‘s austere form. The minimalist Scandinavian-inspired interior matches its style nicely.
Interior and Tech
You‘ll enjoy premium materials and ergonomics inside the C40 along with Google built-in services. Advanced safety features like blind spot monitoring with steering assist demonstrate Volvo‘s uncompromising commitment to safety.
Summary
The Volvo C40 Recharge is a great option for buyers seeking cutting-edge electric capability paired with Volvo‘s trademark emphasis on luxury and safety.
The Takeaway
The Tesla Model Y set the pace for affordable electric SUVs, but the increasing competition has yielded several outstanding alternatives with unique strengths. Buyers now have more choice than ever based on priorities like cost, range, brand experience and styling preference. While the Model Y remains popular, it no longer stands unchallenged as the default option in the segment.
