Skip to content

The Athens of the North: How Edinburgh‘s New Town Became the Epitome of Georgian Elegance

Perched atop its craggy volcanic seat, Edinburgh has long been a city of contrasts. Medieval wynds and closes weave through the Old Town beneath the brooding walls of the castle. Yet cross the invisible boundary into the New Town and you enter a different world entirely – one of sweeping neoclassical crescents, palatial townhouses, and expansive verdant squares.

This is the New Town of Edinburgh, a masterpiece of Georgian urban planning that transformed the city in the 18th century. Its ordered grid of grand boulevards and elegant facades became a model for cities across Europe, earning Edinburgh the moniker "Athens of the North." But how did this dramatic metamorphosis come to pass?

A City Bursting at the Seams

To understand the impetus behind the New Town, we must first picture Edinburgh in the early 1700s. The Scottish capital was a medieval warren, its 50,000 residents crammed into the narrow confines of the Royal Mile and its adjoining closes. Overcrowding was severe, with multiple families sharing cramped tenements of up to 15 stories high.[^1]

Sanitation was abysmal. The Old Town lacked sewers and running water, so chamber pots were simply dumped into the gutters. Fetid pools accumulated in the Nor‘ Loch – now the site of Princes Street Gardens – which had long served as the city‘s cesspit. Disease was rampant, with epidemics of cholera, typhus, and smallpox regularly ravaging the population.[^2]

Narrow timber-framed buildings, coated in flammable pitch for weatherproofing, meant devastating fires were common. Major blazes in 1700, 1721, and 1731 each destroyed hundreds of homes.[^3] Crime and social unrest also plagued the Old Town, fueled by poverty, religious strife, and the bitter political divides of the Jacobite era.

The final catalyst for change came on the night of 3 August 1751, when a dilapidated tenement on the Royal Mile collapsed without warning, killing 66 people. Among the victims were members of some of Edinburgh‘s most prominent families, who had been socializing in the tavern on the ground floor.[^4]

Surveys in the aftermath found that many other structures in the Old Town were similarly unstable. For a city with aspirations of joining the ranks of great European capitals, it was clear that drastic measures were needed.[^5]

A New Town for a New Age

The man who would lead Edinburgh out of its malaise was George Drummond, a visionary civic leader who served six terms as Lord Provost. Drummond recognized that for the city to thrive, it needed to expand beyond the constrictive medieval walls and provide a more salubrious environment for its growing professional and merchant classes.[^6]

His solution was audacious: to construct an entirely new district to the north of the Nor‘ Loch Valley on the open fields extending to the Firth of Forth. It was to be a planned community from the ground up, with wide streets, public squares, gardens, and grand townhouses in the fashionable Palladian style.

To fund this ambitious scheme, Drummond lobbied for the passage of the Improvement Act of 1752. This groundbreaking legislation granted the city the authority to raise bonds for civic development, making the New Town one of the first publicly financed urban planning projects in history.[^7]

Drummond also enlisted the help of Lord Chief Baron Ord, head of the Scottish Exchequer, to address the long-standing problem of the polluted Nor‘ Loch. Ord authorized a plan to drain the loch and transform it into a public park, creating a picturesque boundary between the Old and New Towns.[^8]

With the financing and groundwork in place, in 1766 the city launched a public competition to design the New Town. The winning entry came from James Craig, a 26-year-old architect who had trained under the preeminent Scottish Palladian William Adam.[^9]

A Triumph of Order and Elegance

Craig‘s plan was a masterpiece of axial symmetry and classical proportions. At its heart was a rigid gridiron of three parallel main roads oriented east-west: Princes Street to the south, George Street bisecting the development, and Queen Street to the north.[^10]

These grand boulevards were 100 feet wide and up to half a mile long, a vast change in scale from the narrow, twisted warrens of the Old Town.[^11] Smaller cross streets divided the grid into rectangular blocks, with the largest earmarked for public squares and gardens to serve as communal spaces for promenading and recreation.

The architecture was to be uniform and restrained, with strict guidelines on building heights, materials, and styles to create a harmonious ensemble. Townhouses were constructed in the Palladian manner, with simple yet elegant facades of locally quarried sandstone, punctuated by rows of large sash windows to maximize light and air circulation.[^12]

Subtle details pay homage to Edinburgh‘s political context. In the wake of the Jacobite uprisings, the New Town‘s street names read as a geography of loyalism to the Hanoverian crown: Rose and Thistle Streets for the official flowers of England and Scotland; Hanover and Frederick Streets for the ruling dynasty; and of course the great triumvirate of Princes, George, and Queen.[^13]

Construction on the New Town proceeded in stages over several decades, with the eastern sections completed first in the 1770s-90s, followed by the western extensions in the early 19th century.[^14] Major landmarks arose to anchor the development, from the neoclassical domes and colonnades of Register House to the sprawling villas of Charlotte Square.

By 1800, the New Town housed over 7,000 residents, drawn predominantly from the ranks of the gentry, professionals, and prosperous merchants.[^15] This exodus of the well-heeled from the Old Town led to a marked social segregation between the two districts that would persist for generations.

Enlightenment in Stone

Beyond its innovative urban plan, the New Town also embodied the intellectual spirit of the Scottish Enlightenment. Many of the leading figures of this golden age of philosophy, literature, and science made their homes in its fashionable precincts.

David Hume, the empiricist philosopher and historian, was an early resident of St. David Street, where he wrote his influential "Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion."[^16] Adam Smith developed the foundations of modern economics at his home on Panmure House, just off the Canongate.[^17]

Other luminaries like the geologist James Hutton, the painter Allan Ramsay, and the inventor James Watt were also fixtures of New Town society, congregating in its elegant drawing rooms and at the debating clubs of the Poker and the Select Society.[^18]

The New Town thus became both a backdrop and a crucible for the exchange of Enlightenment ideas, which flowed seamlessly between its private and public spaces. The grid plan, with its broad streets and squares, encouraged chance meetings and promenading, facilitating the cross-pollination of ideas across different social circles and disciplines.[^19]

This notion of the New Town as an Enlightenment city made manifest even extended to its visual connection to classical antiquity. On the northern edge, Calton Hill was transformed into an acropolis for Edinburgh, sprouting monuments in the Greek Revival style like the Burns Monument, the Dugald Stewart Monument, and the National Monument, modeled after the Parthenon.[^20]

Though the National Monument was left unfinished in 1829 due to lack of funds, its twelve Doric columns still stand as a potent symbol of Edinburgh‘s identity as the "Athens of the North," a city where the philosophical and aesthetic values of ancient Greece were reborn in the modern age.

A Model for the World

The influence of Edinburgh‘s New Town extended far beyond the city limits. Its blend of classical architecture, green spaces, and rational planning became the gold standard for urban development in the Georgian era, shaping the appearance of cities across Britain and its colonies.[^21]

The New Town‘s DNA can be seen in the elegant crescents of Bath, the leafy squares of London‘s Bloomsbury and Belgravia, and the grids of Glasgow‘s Merchant City and Dublin‘s Georgian core.[^22] Further afield, echoes of Craig‘s plan are evident in the downtowns of Philadelphia, Savannah, and Sydney, as well as the New Town of Prague.[^23]

This international diffusion was facilitated by the rise of pattern books like Robert and James Adam‘s "Works in Architecture," which spread the Palladian-influenced neo-classical style of the New Town to provincial builders and craftsmen.[^24] Edinburgh thus became a key node in a global network of Georgian architecture and town planning.

The New Town also heralded a broader shift in how cities were conceptualized and developed in the modern era. Its success demonstrated that urban growth could be proactively shaped through rational planning and public financing, rather than simply left to the whims of private speculation and piecemeal development.[^25]

In this sense, the New Town laid the groundwork for the great experiments in urban planning of the 19th and 20th centuries, from the Garden Cities of Ebenezer Howard to the Radiant City of Le Corbusier. Though its geometric regularity and social segregation would later be critiqued, its emphasis on livability, green space, and aesthetic uniformity set a new standard for urban design.[^26]

An Enduring Legacy

Over 250 years since its inception, the New Town remains one of the crown jewels of Georgian architecture and a defining feature of Edinburgh‘s cityscape. Its stately crescents and verdant squares continue to enchant visitors from around the world, drawn to its aura of elegance and Enlightenment.

In 1995, the New Town was designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site, along with the neighboring Old Town, in recognition of their "outstanding universal value" as an ensemble.[^27] This designation has helped to protect the New Town‘s historic fabric and ensure that any new development respects its unique character and scale.

Yet the New Town is more than just a pretty façade or a museum piece frozen in time. Its public spaces continue to serve as a vital social nexus for the city, from the farmers‘ market on Castle Terrace to the festivals and concerts in Princes Street Gardens.[^28] Its handsome townhouses and tenements remain highly desirable addresses, home to a diverse mix of residents, businesses, and institutions.

As Edinburgh has grown and evolved in the intervening centuries, the New Town has proven remarkably adaptable to changing times and tastes. Its flexible grid plan and spacious proportions have accommodated a wide range of uses, from offices and shops to hotels and universities, without compromising its essential character.[^29]

At the same time, the New Town‘s legacy has also been a source of tension and critique. Its creation exacerbated social and economic disparities between the Old and New Towns, with the latter becoming an exclusive enclave of the wealthy and privileged.[^30] The strict uniformity of its architecture and plan has also been seen as stifling to more organic and diverse forms of urban vitality.[^31]

Nonetheless, the New Town endures as a testament to the transformative power of visionary urban planning and design. Its success in turning Edinburgh from a medieval backwater into a beacon of Enlightenment modernity offers enduring lessons for cities seeking to balance growth, livability, and heritage in the face of change.

As we grapple with the challenges of urbanization in the 21st century, from sustainability and affordability to resilience and inclusivity, the New Town reminds us of the importance of thinking big and bold in shaping the future of our cities. For in its elegant streets and stately stones, we see not just a triumph of the Georgian age, but a timeless model of what is possible when we dare to imagine a better urban world.

[^1]: Youngson, A.J. (1966) The Making of Classical Edinburgh. Edinburgh University Press. p. 1
[^2]: McKean, Charles (2005) Edinburgh: An Illustrated Architectural Guide. Rutland Press. pp. 62-63
[^3]: Coghill, Hamish (2008) Lost Edinburgh. Birlinn Ltd. pp. 30-31
[^4]: Glendinning, Miles; MacKechnie, Aonghus (2004). Scottish Architecture. Thames & Hudson. p. 106
[^5]: Mackean, Charles (1992) Edinburgh: An Illustrated Architectural Guide. Rutland Press. pp. 62-63
[^6]: Youngson, A.J. (1966) The Making of Classical Edinburgh 1750-1840. Edinburgh University Press. p. 24
[^7]: Fraser, Andrew (1989) The Building of Old College: Adam, Playfair & the University of Edinburgh. Edinburgh University Press. p. 59
[^8]: Catford, E.F. (1975) Edinburgh: The Story of a City. Hutchinson. p. 138
[^9]: Lowrey, John (2001). "From Caesarea to Athens: Greek Revival Edinburgh and the Question of Scottish Identity within the Unionist State". Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians. 60 (2): 136–157.
[^10]: Lowrey, John (1996) From Castles to Tenements: Scottish Architecture 1450-1750. Renzo Piano Workshop. p. 59
[^11]: McWilliam, Colin; Walker, David (1984) Edinburgh. Penguin Books. p. 167
[^12]: Howard, Deborah (1995). The Architectural History of Scotland: Scottish Architecture from the Reformation to the Restoration, 1560–1660. Edinburgh University Press.
[^13]: Miller, Phil (25 January 2019). "Auld Reekie to Athens of the North: Edinburgh‘s Dramatic Transformation". The Herald.
[^14]: Lowrey, John (2001). The New Town of Edinburgh: An Architectural Celebration. John Donald. pp. 10-11
[^15]: Youngson, A.J. (1966) The Making of Classical Edinburgh. Edinburgh University Press. p. 70
[^16]: Daiches, David (1978). Edinburgh. Hamish Hamilton. p. 167
[^17]: Buchan, James (2003). Crowded with Genius: The Scottish Enlightenment: Edinburgh‘s Moment of the Mind. HarperCollins. pp. 80-81
[^18]: Berry, Christopher J. (2008) The Idea of Commercial Society in the Scottish Enlightenment. Edinburgh University Press. p. 20
[^19]: Lowrey, John (1996) From Castles to Tenements: Scottish Architecture 1450-1750. Renzo Piano Workshop. p. 60
[^20]: Theodossopoulos, Dimitris (2012). "The National Monument of Scotland: A Architectural Analysis" in Neo-Classical Edinburgh. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 51-62
[^21]: Edwards, Brian (2006). Edinburgh: The Making of a Capital City. Edinburgh University Press. p. 4
[^22]: Jenkins, Simon (2008). Scotland‘s 100 Best Buildings. Penguin Books. p. xvi
[^23]: Cruft, Kitty; Fraser, Andrew; Lewis, Midori Yamamura (2006). The Town Plans of Scotland: Edinburgh Section. Birlinn Ltd. p. 121
[^24]: Gow, Ian (2006). Scotland‘s Lost Houses. Aurum Press. p. 129
[^25]: Youngson, A.J. (2001). The Companion Guide to Edinburgh and the Borders. Companion Guides. p. 72
[^26]: Gelernter, Mark (2001). A History of American Architecture: Buildings in Their Cultural and Technological Context. Manchester University Press. p. 155
[^27]: "Old and New Towns of Edinburgh". UNESCO World Heritage Centre.
[^28]: "Things to Do in Edinburgh New Town". This is Edinburgh.
[^29]: McCrone, David; Morris, Angela; Kiely, Richard (1995). Scotland – The Brand: The Making of Scottish Heritage. Edinburgh University Press. p. 66
[^30]: Rodger, Richard (2001). The Transformation of Edinburgh: Land, Property and Trust in the Nineteenth Century. Cambridge University Press. pp. 266-267
[^31]: Rae, Isobel; Rae, Patricia (2008). Forgotten Edinburgh. The History Press. p. 27