Skip to content

AT&T Versus Xfinity: How The Telecom Giants Compare on Internet Service

Internet connectivity forms the lifeline of modern life. As telecom titans AT&T and Comcast continue building out fiber optic and high-speed cable networks, consumers rightfully want to know: how do these two internet service giants compare when it comes to speed, reliability and value?

This comprehensive technology guide examines all the crucial factors to evaluate when choosing between AT&T Internet and Xfinity for home broadband access.

A Brief History of Connectivity Leaders

The Rise of Ma Bell‘s ISP Empire

AT&T‘s history stretches back to Alexander Graham Bell‘s breakthrough invention of the telephone in 1876. Fast forward to 1983, and AT&T‘s local exchange carriers began offering early dial-up internet access. After a series of mergers, SBC Communications acquired the iconic AT&T Corp. brand in 2005, then rolled out AT&T U-Verse fiber services starting in 2006.

AT&T History Timeline

Key AT&T Milestones:

  • 1983 – AT&T unveils dial-up internet access
  • 2000 – Launches DSL broadband service
  • 2006 – Debuts U-Verse TV and internet
  • 2014 – Acquires DirecTV
  • 2016 – Splits IP broadband and video services into AT&T Internet and DirecTV brands

AT&T Internet continues relying on a digital subscriber line (DSL) network built largely on old telephone infrastructure as well as newer fiber optic cables powering its growing AT&T Fiber footprint.

The Cable Colossus

Comcast emerged as a regional cable TV provider in 1963 under the name American Cable Systems. Over years of rapid growth through acquisitions, Comcast became the dominant player in cable internet and television.

Xfinity & Comcast History

Major Comcast & Xfinity Milestones:

  • 1963 – Founded as American Cable Systems
  • 2001 – Becomes largest cable operator after acquiring AT&T cable assets
  • 2010 – Rebrands consumer services under Xfinity
  • 2013 – Acquires remaining stake in NBCUniversal
  • 2022 – Reaches 194K route miles of hybrid fiber coax network

Today Comcast continues upgrading its vast network from older coaxial cable to high-capacity fiber optics and DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem technology capable of multi-gigabit speeds. Xfinity represents the consumer-facing brand bundling Comcast‘s internet, TV, home and mobile services.

Breaking Down Network Architectures

The physical internet connections reaching homes and devices rely on various network technologies. AT&T and Comcast take markedly different approaches to data transmission with tradeoffs customers should understand.

AT&T Internet Infrastructure

The foundation of AT&T‘s internet service rests on digital subscriber line (DSL) over telephone copper wiring. This DSL network uses fiber optic lines connected to neighborhood service nodes. However, the so-called "last-mile" stretches from nodes to individual buildings still depend on copper wires originally installed for landlines.

DSL download speeds generally top out around 100 Mbps for subscribers located close to their service node. Performance degrades over longer copper distances. Rural regions on outdated infrastructure suffer slow speeds under 10 Mbps.

To compete with cable, AT&T began building out fiber-to-the-premises (FTTP) delivering dedicated fiber optic strands straight to homes and offices. AT&T Fiber provides future-proof connectivity with symmetrical upload and download speeds. While much faster than DSL, fiber availability remains limited.

AT&T High-Speed Internet Infrastructure

Technology Max Download Speed Latency Availability
Fiber to the Premises (FTTP) 1 Gbps Ultra Low Limited fiber footprint
Fiber to the Node (FTTN) 100 Mbps Low Available for most DSL subscribers
Legacy DSL 10 Mbps High Dates back to telephone lines

Xfinity Cable and Fiber Networks

In contrast to AT&T‘s fiber-DSL combo, Comcast Xfinity primarily relies on the reach of its massive hybrid fiber-coaxial (HFC) cable network. This network combines fiber optic trunk lines with coaxial cable connections to individual locations.

The workhorse behind Xfinity internet is DOCSIS 3.1 cable modem technology theoretically capable of 10 Gbps downloads by bonding multiple channels. Actual customer speeds range from 25 Mbps to 1.2 Gbps based on service tiers.

Recognizing fiber will future-proof next-gen speeds, Comcast continues migrating customers in certain metro areas to dedicated fiber lines. The company expects to expand fiber to reach 50 million homes and businesses before 2025.

Xfinity High-Speed Internet Infrastructure

Technology Max Download Speed Latency Availability
Fiber to the Premises (FTTP) 6 Gbps Extremely Low Limited but growing footprint
DOCSIS 3.1 Cable 1.2 Gbps Very Low Available for most cable subscribers
Legacy Cable 100 Mbps Low-Medium Dates back to initial coaxial buildouts

Speed Test Showdowns: AT&T vs Xfinity

Independent testing offers an unbiased look at how AT&T and Comcast internet speeds hold up compared to advertised rates. According to massive crowdsourced samples from speed testing firm Ookla, Xfinity consistently outperforms AT&T.

Speed Scorecard: AT&T Internet

  • AT&T Fiber 300 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 283 Mbps
  • AT&T Internet 75 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 70.41 Mbps
  • AT&T Internet 50 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 46.27 Mbps
  • AT&T Internet 25 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 20.33 Mbps

Ookla speed tests during Q3 and Q4 2022 indicate AT&T fiber subscribers enjoy 98% of advertised speeds on average. However, DSL-based plans often fall short of max speed claims, especially for lower tiers.

Speed Scorecard: Xfinity

  • Xfinity 1000 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 877 Mbps
  • Xfinity 400 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 437 Mbps
  • Xfinity 200 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median = 211 Mbps
  • Xfinity 25 Mbps Plan – Ookla Median Speed = 31 Mbps

Across all speed tiers, Ookla verifies Xfinity subscribers see 80-90% of advertised maximum downloads. While gigabit plans can exhibit some speed overload during peak congestion, Xfinity network capacity upgraded to DOCSIS 3.1 keeps pace overall with customer demand.

Availability: Who Has the Widest Reach?

Accessing fast, reliable internet hinges largely on location. With a presence spanning over 40 states, Xfinity by Comcast enjoys roughly double the infrastructure footprint versus 21 state availability for AT&T Internet.

Infrastructure gaps show up conspicuously on coverage maps, even in well-populated areas. For instance, AT&T fiber concentrates heavily in states like California, while missing large swaths Iowa subscribers who can only get 10 Mbps DSL. Xfinity provides broader cable access, but typically competes against local telcos outside Comcast service areas.

Let‘s examine regional availability more closely.

AT&T and Xfinity coverage and availability map

Midwest: Outside certain metro pockets, Xfinity coverage dominates over AT&T availability stretching across Illinois, Michigan, Ohio and beyond. Fiber competition comes from local providers like CenturyLink or Metronet rather than AT&T.

Southeast: AT&T internet enjoys its strongest foothold across southern states with fiber popping up around cities like Atlanta and Nashville. Xfinity makes deeper inroads across Florida and along the coast.

Southwest: AT&T recently completed fiber buildouts across Los Angeles and parts of California. However, Xfinity cable offers wider access for California subscribers plus broader reach extending east through desert regions.

Northeast Corridor: Residents up and down the Boston-Washington megalopolis generally face a cable vs phone company decision: Xfinity or Verizon Fios. Limited AT&T presence comes into play.

Evaluating regional availability matters when weighing AT&T vs Xfinity. Even the fastest internet can’t satisfy if fiber or cable hasn’t reached your block yet.

Customer Satisfaction: Who Does it Better?

Along with speeds and availability, customer ratings offer perhaps the most telling metric when comparing internet providers.

Analyzing data from American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), Consumer Reports and J.D. Power paints a picture of mediocre satisfaction with major ISPs. However, Xfinity consistently outscores AT&T Internet for service quality and reliability.

Let‘s break down the consumer sentiment regarding these telecom giants:

American Customer Satisfaction Index

  • Comcast Xfinity: ASCI Score = 62
  • AT&T Internet: ASCI Score = 56

While both companies have room for improvement, Xfinity manages moderately higher customer satisfaction. Top complaints for AT&T include slower-than-advertised speeds and frequent connection dropouts.

Consumer Reports Survey

  • Xfinity Overall Customer Satisfaction: 63 points
  • AT&T Internet Overall Satisfaction: 54 points

A similar story emerges with Consumer Reports data based on member surveys. Contributors rated Xfinity appreciably better for value, speed consistency and ease of setup.

JD Power 2022 ISP Satisfaction Study

  • Xfinity Internet Overall Satisfaction Rank: #5 nationally
  • AT&T Internet Overall Satisfaction Rank: #11 nationally

According to tech analyst firm J.D. Power, Xfinity places among the top ISPs for customer satisfaction. AT&T Internet occupies the bottom third of rankings nationally for factors like performance, billing, and communication.

While far from beloved, Comcast Xfinity makes stronger showings over AT&T for satisfying internet subscribers. Support service shortcomings remain an opportunity for both brands.

Bundles: Xfinity Edges Ahead

Bundling home services together—internet, TV and mobile—stands as a leading perk for loyal customers.

AT&T entices subscribers to bundle in DIRECTV for satellite TV or streaming service AT&T TV. Savings become substantial when adding TV, AT&T Internet and wireless phone plans. However, the poor DIRECTV acquisition saw subscribers flee in recent years.

In contrast, Xfinity bundles gain appeal by integrating mobile and home connectivity. Many Xfinity internet customers double up with Xfinity Mobile leveraging Verizon‘s coverage. Bundling also incorporates the Xfinity Flex app for streaming shows, movies and more.

As cord-cutting accelerates, Xfinity appears better positioned to adapt TV viewing behaviors while keeping subscribers contained via mobile service. Still, whether bundling wireless plans makes financial sense depends on individual usage.

Cost Comparison: Price Hike Pitfalls

Selecting the best value for money represents another chief consideration when signing an internet contract. Teaser rates lure in customers upfront before regular pricing takes hold, so comparing true long-term costs makes astute financial sense.

We‘ll analyze some of the biggest pain points and hidden fees accompanying AT&T and Xfinity internet plans below.

Price comparison chart showing total 2 year cost for AT&T Internet vs Xfinity

AT&T Internet Cost Considerations

  • Lengthy contracts + Early Termination Fees
  • Advertised pricing good for just 12 months
  • Equipment rental fees
  • $10 per 50 GB over 1TB data cap

Xfinity Internet Cost Considerations

  • No term contracts but stand-alone pricing jumps after 1 year
  • Taxes and regional sports fees can add $15+ per month
  • Modem rental fees after 30 days
  • Overlimit charges beyond 1.2 TB data cap

The bottom line: both AT&T and Xfinity lure subscribers with tempting sign-up discounts before sticker shock sets in on later bills. Savvy customers can sidestep nasty surprises by understanding long-term commitments and added fees upfront.

Which Provider Reigns Supreme for Internet Service?

Declaring one unambiguous victor in a category as location-dependent as internet remains improbable. Delivering a verdict on AT&T Internet vs Xfinity comes layered with nuances tied to availability in specific neighborhoods.

However, analyzing technology capabilities, independent speed tests, consumer satisfaction benchmarks and pricing transparency provides sufficient evidence for recommendations:

  • AT&T fiber-based internet plans merit strong consideration where available thanks to affordability and lag-free connectivity.

  • For widespread cable availability at faster rates than DSL, Comcast Xfinity usually wins out.

  • Xfinity also holds the edge for bundle incentives alongside customer support.

Of course, most searchers aren‘t making a hypothetical choice but rather deciding between the existing providers serving their address. Both AT&T and Xfinity continue expanding fiber optics and next-gen cable to jockey for subscribers the old fashioned way—block by block.