Skip to content

Starlink vs Viasat: How Do the Major Satellite Internet Providers Compare?

High-speed satellite internet was once considered impossible. Restrictive data caps, high latency, unreliable connections, and restrictive hardware rendered it an option of last resort. But breakthroughs in satellite and networking technologies have yielded a new wave of high-performance solutions – with Starlink and Viasat most prominent among them.

This guide offers an in-depth, side-by-side comparison of Starlink and Viasat across critical metrics including speed, latency, data caps, contracts, and hardware. It also dives deep into the technology, business models, and long-term visions enabling these achievements. Which provider comes out on top for most consumer and business use cases? Read on to find out.

The Dawn of High-Performance Satellite Internet

Legacy satellite internet providers have been beaming IP traffic from space since the late 90s. But performance was held back by the physics of distant geosynchronous orbits. Without a massive leap forward in satellite and networking hardware, latency over 500 ms and jitter would continue limiting applications.

Enter SpaceX and their Starlink constellation system. By leveraging mass-produced small satellites in low earth orbit, phased array antennas, and high-throughput ground links, the impossible became reality: satellite internet on par with cable and fiber.

Overcoming the Limits of Distance and Physics

Viasat relies on only 2-3 satellites parked in geosynchronous orbit (GEO) about 22,000 miles above earth. Signals must travel a long distance, ultimately limiting speed of light performance. Starlink takes a completely different approach using over 1,000 compact satellites in low earth orbit between 340 to 714 miles high instead. This allows radio waves to traverse the vacuum of space for 90% less distance. Rather than a few expensive satellites, Starlink optis for mass-produced commodity hardware and smarter software for flexible coverage, upgrading capability over 5-7 year lifespan, and seamless replacement.

Viasat is also exploring medium earth orbit constellations to bolster capacity but has vastly fewer satellites than Starlink presently. The simple physics of less distance gives Starlink an innate advantage.

Delivering Fiber-Like Responsiveness

Starlink‘s low earth orbiting satellites cut total signal travel distance down from about 45,000 miles to under 1,000 miles. This allows radio waves to ping geosynchronous satellites in about 500-700 ms – too slow for video calls and gaming. Starlink gets latency down to 20-40 ms – on par with cable and fiber networks – through sheer proximity.

Real-time applications demand responsiveness. Whether live-streaming competitive matches or battles, attended virtual meetings, or remote learning environments, latency dictates experience. Here too Starlink revolutionizes expectations of satellite connectivity.

Advanced Networking Maximizes Speeds

With vastly more aggregate bandwidth supply from its swarm of satellites, Starlink focuses on throughput and consistency. Using advanced ground station phased array antennas tracking satellites passing overhead, network traffic can be balanced across satellites and backhaul links dynamically. The result is 150 Mbps class download speeds far eclipsing Viasat‘s capped rates.

Souping up their two satellites further can’t match an entire fleet of progress. Starlink’s space-based backbone scales more easily, delivering abundant bandwidth for all environments. For rural users, that meanssmooth 4K streaming and video calls previously impossible. Businesses also benefit from high capacity and redundant satellite links outnumbering Viasat’s.

Hands Down Performance Winner: Starlink

Advantages in latency, throughput, and network responsiveness power tangible experience gains for Starlink users versus Viasat – particularly in internet performance sensitive use cases.

Speed and Data Caps: No Competition

Starlink download speeds obliterate Viasat in real-world testing based on user data. Viasat sells plans advertising "up to" 25 Mbps but most users actually obtain 3-4 Mbps based on capacity limitations. Plus restrictive data caps from 40-150 GB on those plans make sustained use impossible.

Meanwhile, SpaceX configures infrastructure for consistent 50-150 Mbps class performance to delight customers rather than oversell capacity. Many users enjoy speeds well over 100 Mbps suitable for a packed household of streamers.

Starlink Viasat
Avg Download Speed 110 Mbps 3-4 Mbps
Data Caps None 40-150 GB

Unleashed by unlimited data, 4K video streaming, video calls, and gaming are silky smooth thanks to extreme speed advantages.

Responsiveness for Real-Time Apps

That sentiment holds true for latency-sensitive use cases as well. Satellite internet historically struggles with 500+ ms ping times, introducing noticeable lags in video calls, virtual meetings, and cloud gaming. Even the most geographically direct fiber connections ping around 30 ms latency across long distances.

Starlink Viasat
Average Latency 31 ms 569 ms

Starlink again revolutionizes expectations by serving latency matching fiber network performance thanks to its low orbiting fleet. Interactive apps are far more usable as a result compared to Viasat‘s offering.

Gaming and Streaming: No Contest

For online gaming, streaming HD and 4K video content, and video conferencing, Starlink simply runs laps around Viasat. These use cases represent some of the fastest growing internet traffic segments as entertainment and workplace norms continue evolving.

Let‘s examine popular applications more closely:

  • PC/Console Gaming – Fast twitch genres like competitive first person shooters demand low latency for rewarding play. Starlink’s 30 ms ping delivers a fair fight while Viasat’s 500+ ms pings allow opponents to flank your position before seeing them on your screen.

  • Cloud Gaming – Graphics-intensive titles require high and steady bandwidth so the compressed video stream keeps up. Regular buffering and pixelation quickly ruins immersion making cloud gaming unworkable on Viasat.

  • Video Streaming – Attention spans today little tolerate choppy video. Consistent 100+ Mbps throughput lets Starlink customers stream 4K content smoothly with no worries while Viasat sputters on HD.

  • Video Calls/Virtual Meetings – Latency above 500 ms manifests as awkward gaps in conversation and stilted pacing. Starlink makes these applications feel natural and flowing.

For these mainstream use cases, Viasat‘s sluggish performance simply doesn‘t cut it anymore while Starlink matches and beats wired connectivity.

Game Changing Potential for Underserved Markets

Perhaps most transformational is Starlink‘s promise for rural and developing markets. While urban dwellers enjoy ever increasing wired bandwidth through cable and fiber builds, rural regions frequently lack meaningful internet options or pay exorbitant prices for poor fixed wireless services.

Starlink aims to bridge this yawning digital divide by launching satellite-based broadband cheaper than running fiber. Already user terminals are connecting remote villages from the Canadian wilderness to Australian outback.

Connecting the Next Billion Users

And Starlink has scarcely gotten started. The company is still launching additional satellites to achieve seamless global coverage while scaling up production on millions of user terminals.

Viasat too has some small community ISP wins but lacks capacity for addressing internet disenfranchised populations at scale like Starlink can. Higher satellite production costs and extensive ground infrastructure require make rural networks less economically viable.

Early government sponsored projects provide clues to just how expansive Starlink‘s societal reach could become. For comparison, Viasat’s ViaSat-3 satellites each support about 1 million subscribers. SpaceX has manufactured over 2000 low-cost satellites already, adding capacity for over 10 million concurrent users.

Thanks to space-based delivery, Starlink aims to bring high speed access within financial reach of over 5 billion globally lacking reasonable connectivity today.

Why Starlink Has Rural Areas Covered

Starlink’s infrastructure innovations combine to make rural broadband delivery financially sustainable where other options still fail:

  • Low launch costs – Leveraging re-usable rockets, each Starlink launch carries 60 satellites for about $20 million total per mission

  • Mass-produced satellites – Streamlined manufacturing drives costs below $250,000 per satellite

  • Lower user terminal prices – Phased array antennas fabricated on mass scale compared to mechanically steered dishes

  • No hardwire deployment costs – Tens of thousands in fiber/cable plant equipment and installation expenses erased

These transformations alter the entire cost structure equation making rural access profitable. ViaSat spends almost $1 billion per satellite while passing those expenses to customers or taxpayer subsidies. SpaceX spends a fraction as much per satellite and user terminal while still delivering premium performance.

Rural users thus get broadband comparable to city dwellers on reasonable plans instead of heavily marked up tiered services. Businesses also enjoy robust internet enabling work from anywhere.

Business Use Cases and Enterprise Plans

Starlink and Viasat both court business accounts with higher tier offerings. For branch offices in remote locations or temporary venue setups, satellite internet shines by deploying instantly.

Let‘s compare dedicated business plans:

Starlink Business Viasat Business
Max Download Speed 350 Mbps 150 Mbps
SLA Uptime % 99.5% 99.9%
IP Addresses 100 static 30 static
Latency 31 ms 569 ms
Price $500/month $599/month

Reviewing the numbers, Starlink triumphs again on raw speed and responsiveness. Viasat offers better contractual uptime guarantees given a more mature network. But latency remains a nagging experience liability for VoIP, video calls, and cloud apps.

How each scales with more satellite launches may determine long-run suitability. Starlink‘s swarm style architecture could support dedicated enterprise satellite capacity faster through manufacturing and launch cadences.

Transforming Industries

Early customers already showcase revolutionary applications for remote operations and logistics:

  • Emergency services – Connecting ambulances with telemetry data on route to hospitals

  • Disaster recovery – Rapidly restoring communication after floods or fires

  • Maritime operations – High-speed vessel internet halfway across oceans

  • Airline WiFi – Testing 500+ Mbps inflight connections for passengers

  • Mining/Oil/Gas – Monitoring crucial equipment in barren sites

  • Military missions – Secure encrypted broadband for tactical forces’ProgressUpdating Sattelite Constellations Rapidly

These customers need reliability and performance exceeding legacy satellite ISPs. Starlink brings immense bandwidth on tap through continuous enhancement:

  • Adding satellites rapidly thanks to mass production

  • Upgrading satellites every 5-7 years with latest technology

  • Launching new orbital planes for additional capacity

Such iteration speed is impossible with GEO satellites costing over $1 billion each. Starlink‘s model allows scaling capacity faster to more customers in more places.

The Bottom Line

For most residential use cases today, Starlink offers superior satellite internet service over Viasat:

  • 10x faster download speeds enable heavy streaming and downloads
  • Lower latency improves gaming, video calls, and real-time remote use
  • No restrictive data caps let households use internet freely

Rural access represents a multi-billion user business where Viasat has no viable answer to Starlink‘s satellite swarm broadband delivery paradigm.

Still, Viasat retains strengths around business connections and in-flight internet with a longer operating history. We‘ll have to see how their next generation constellations fare in closing the gap if SpaceX executes on scale.

But with groundbreaking experience benefits unlocked through technological leapfrogging, Starlink sits firmly ahead in early innings of an space-based connectivity revolution. As user counts swell into the millions amidst supply shortages, cleary the promise of fast, limitless satellite internet resonates loudly.

The Future of Satellite Internet

Other players like OneWeb or AST SpaceMobile race to expand LEO and MEO fleets to contend while innovating ground antennas and spectrum sharing.

Expect coverage, speeds, reliability to continue improving while latency and hardware costs come down across vendors. But for now, there’s simply no beating Starlink’s sheer satellite scale and low orbit advantages.

With so many unconnected worldwide lacking options today, we need the sky-high thinking Elon Musk engenders. Starlink has already reset expectations on what satellite can deliver. The real race is to proliferate access through manufacturing and launch innovation that improves life for customers whether elite gamer or rural student.

If Starlink achieves aspirations of blanketing the globe with low cost broadband from space, we all win thanks to the productive connections and innovations such access sparks.