Gold has captivated humanity for millennia, its glimmering allure an enduring symbol of wealth and prosperity. In the realm of numismatics, few coins capture this allure quite like the classic U.S. gold dollars struck from 1849-1889. Though diminutive in size, these $1 gold pieces now rank among the most coveted and valuable American coins.
As a lifelong collector and student of numismatic history, I‘ve long been fascinated by the gold dollar series. Over years of collecting, researching, and handling these coins, I‘ve gained a deep appreciation for their rarity, beauty, and historical significance. In this comprehensive guide, I‘ll share my expert insights on gold dollar coin values, key dates, varieties, and collecting strategies.
Whether you‘re a seasoned collector or new to the hobby, I invite you to embark on a journey into the rare and valuable world of gold dollar coins. But fair warning: once you catch "gold fever," there‘s no turning back!
Origins of the Gold Dollar
Our story begins in the late 1840s, a time of immense change and opportunity in America. The California Gold Rush of 1848-1855 flooded the market with newly mined gold, leading Congress to reevaluate U.S. coinage. A year prior, legislation had authorized the issuance of two new gold denominations: the gold dollar and the double eagle ($20).
Tasked with designing the new gold dollar, U.S. Mint Chief Engraver James B. Longacre chose a simple yet elegant motif. The obverse featured a left-facing portrait of Lady Liberty wearing a coronet inscribed with the word "LIBERTY." The reverse depicted a wreath encircling the denomination "1 DOLLAR" and the date.
Longacre‘s Liberty Head design launched in 1849 and remained until 1854. As the first regular-issue U.S. gold coin struck in dollar denomination, the 1849 carries special historical significance and commands a premium from collectors.
Liberty Head Gold Dollar (1849-1854)
The Liberty Head gold dollar, or Type 1, spans a brief but momentous period in U.S. coinage history. Several Branch Mints produced the coin, including the storied Charlotte (C), Dahlonega (D), and New Orleans (O) facilities. As a general rule, coins from these southern mints are scarcer and more valuable than their Philadelphia (no mint mark) counterparts.
However, the rarest regular-issue coin actually comes from Philadelphia: the 1849 Open Wreath, struck for only a few days before the design was modified to strengthen the reverse details. Other important varieties are the 1849-C Open Wreath and the 1849 "No L," missing the "L" initial on the truncation of Liberty‘s neck.
Here‘s a chart of Liberty Head gold dollar values in XF40 and MS65 grades, two common benchmarks (source: PCGS CoinFacts, June 2023):
| Date | XF40 Value | MS65 Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1849 Open Wreath | $35,000 | $400,000 |
| 1849 Closed Wreath | $500 | $25,000 |
| 1850 | $450 | $12,500 |
| 1851 | $450 | $17,500 |
| 1852 | $450 | $30,000 |
| 1853 | $450 | $20,000 |
| 1854 | $450 | $10,000 |
Note the exponential price jump for the 1849 Open Wreath – this legendary rarity can command over $1 million in top Mint State grades! Meanwhile, an attractive circulated example of a common date like 1854 is relatively affordable at under $500.
My expert collecting tip for Type 1 gold dollars: focus on eye appeal and originality over technical grade. A well-struck, minimally marked AU58 coin will be far more desirable than an overgraded or harshly cleaned MS62. Aim for CAC-approved coins when buying sight-unseen or seek the counsel of a specialist gold dealer.
The Brief Era of the Small Head Indian Princess
In 1854, Longacre redesigned the gold dollar with a new motif: a left-facing portrait of Lady Liberty adorned with a feathered headdress, styled as a Native American "Indian Princess." The reverse featured a simple agricultural wreath of corn, wheat, cotton, and tobacco.
This initial version, known as the Type 2 or Small Head design, lasted only until 1856. The relief proved too high and the head size too small for the Mint‘s equipment, resulting in many weakly struck coins. Two key varieties emerged: the extremely rare 1855-D, with only 1,811 minted, and the 1856 Slanted 5, so-named for its distinctive date logotype.
Both varieties rank among the most valuable Type 2 gold dollars. recent auction records include:
- 1855-D MS64: realized $441,250 in 2022 (Heritage Auctions)
- 1856 Slanted 5 MS67: realized $50,400 in 2014 (Heritage Auctions)
Across the board, Type 2 gold dollars are scarce and valuable in all grades. Here‘s a pricing chart for notable dates (source: PCGS CoinFacts, June 2023):
| Date | G4 Value | MS65 Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1854 | $250 | $20,000 |
| 1855 | $250 | $35,000 |
| 1855-D | $25,000 | $400,000 |
| 1856 | $250 | $50,000 |
| 1856 Slanted 5 | $500 | $85,000 |
My collecting advice for Type 2 gold dollars emphasizes patience and selectivity. These coins are not easy to locate, especially in original, problem-free condition. Don‘t settle for the first example you find – wait for a coin with full LIBERTY, sharp headdress details, and actual mint luster. Few coins are as visually striking as a gem Type 2 gold dollar.
The Enduring Design: Large Head Indian Princess
For the final 34 years of the series, from 1856-1889, the Mint modified Longacre‘s Indian Princess design into what collectors know as the Type 3 or Large Head motif. The most significant change was an enlargement of Liberty‘s portrait, filling more of the obverse field. Longacre also reworked the reverse wreath for clarity and visual appeal.
Though the longest-lived gold dollar type, the Large Head contains some of the lowest mintage figures in U.S. coinage history. In 1875, a mere 400 business strikes were produced! Other notable rarities include the 1861-D (1,250 struck), 1863 (6,200 struck), and 1873 Closed 3 (1,800 struck).
Here‘s a sample of Type 3 gold dollar values, focusing on the key dates (source: PCGS CoinFacts, June 2023):
| Date | AU50 Value | MS65 Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1861-D | $22,500 | $125,000 |
| 1863 | $12,500 | $115,000 |
| 1873 Closed 3 | $30,000 | $175,000 |
| 1875 | $100,000 | $550,000 |
| 1884 | $650 | $37,500 |
| 1889 | $600 | $22,500 |
The prime collecting strategy I recommend for Type 3 gold dollars is to specialize by year. Choose a less popular but still scarce date like 1884 or 1889 and seek the finest certified example in your budget. You‘ll face less competition than for an 1875 while still owning a significant, low-mintage rarity.
The Factors Behind Gold Dollar Values
So why are 19th century gold dollars so valuable compared to their modern golden-colored cousins? It comes down to the interplay of four key factors: rarity, gold content, condition, and demand.
Rarity: Simply put, classic gold dollars are rare coins. Of the 19 million struck, only a tiny fraction survive for collectors today. The Mint melted millions of uncurrent gold dollars following the Gold Recall Act of 1933 and the Gold Reserve Act of 1934. Untold others were lost, damaged, or circulated into oblivion.
Gold content: Each gold dollar contains .04837 troy ounces of pure gold, 90% of its total weight. With gold prices around $2,000 per ounce as of June 2023, that intrinsic value alone is nearly $100. Of course, numismatic value far exceeds melt value for these coins. An 1889-P in MS-60 is worth about $1,000 – a 10x premium over gold content!
Condition: As with all coins, state of preservation has an immense impact on gold dollar values. The 70-point Sheldon grading scale is exponential, not linear. An 1854-P graded PCGS MS63 is worth $5,000, while the same coin in PCGS MS67 nets nearly $90,000. Aim for problem-free coins with original surfaces and full striking detail.
Demand: High-grade gold dollars have always captivated top collectors willing to pay strong premiums. The 1854-P PCGS PR65DCAM that set the gold dollar record at $720,000? That coin last sold in 2005. Who knows what it would bring today! As a finite resource, these coins have inherently limited supply. But collector demand, spurred by registry sets and the allure of gold, remains strong.
Gold Dollars vs. Modern Golden Dollars
You may wonder why I‘ve focused exclusively on classic 19th-century gold dollars and not the modern "golden dollars" introduced in 2000. The reason is simple: there‘s really no comparison in value or collectibility. Modern golden dollars like the Sacagawea, Native American, and Presidential issues are made from a copper core clad in manganese brass. They contain no precious metal whatsoever.
These coins were struck by the billions, meaning even pristine certified examples are worth $100 or less. Only rare errors and varieties like the 2000-P Sacagawea/Washington quarter "mule" rise to four- and five-figure values.
That‘s not to discourage anyone from collecting modern dollar coins. They make affordable and attractive collectibles with some interesting varieties to pursue. Just don‘t expect them to approach classic gold dollars in terms of rarity, value, or historical significance.
Tips for Collecting Gold Dollars
As we‘ve seen, building a set of 19th-century gold dollars is no small undertaking. Rare dates routinely sell for five and even six figures in choice uncirculated grades. So how can you get started as a collector of these valuable coins? Here are my top expert tips:
-
Buy the book before the coin. Invest in gold dollar reference books from Q. David Bowers, David Akers, and Walter Breen. Study the series in detail before making major purchases.
-
Set a budget and collecting goals. Decide which types or dates you‘ll focus on and what grade range fits your budget. Consider starting with circulated examples of scarcer dates over low-end Mint State common dates.
-
Stick with PCGS and NGC. For high-value gold dollars, a certificate is a must. These leading grading services have consistent standards and strong reputations. Beware of off-brand "slabs!"
-
Prioritize eye appeal. Technical grade is important, but a coin‘s visual attractiveness matters just as much for liquidity and pride of ownership. Avoid questionable color, heavy marks, or weak strikes. Use images, not just grade, to evaluate potential purchases.
-
Work with trusted dealers. Develop relationships with specialist dealers in 19th-century gold. Be willing to pay fair market prices for accurately graded, CAC-approved coins from sources with proven track records.
-
Handle with care! Gold is a soft metal and these are small coins. Only touch the edges and store in non-PVC inert plastic holders. Avoid harsh cleaners and treatments at all costs.
A Golden Opportunity
As we‘ve journeyed through the history, rarity, and value of gold dollar coins, I hope you‘ve gained a new appreciation for these numismatic treasures. From the first historic 1849 issues to the final 1889 deliveries, each coin tells a story and captures a moment in America‘s golden age.
Owning a choice, original gold dollar is a privilege and a pleasure. The satisfaction of completing a Gold Type Set or landing a key date like the 1861-D is unmatched in our hobby. Whether you‘re drawn to the financial or historical value, the undeniable beauty, or the "wow factor" of a CAC-stickered gem, gold dollars have much to offer collectors of all levels.
If you‘re ready to discover the rare and valuable world of gold dollar coins, I invite you to immerse yourself in these fascinating pieces of Americana. Study the series, set your goals, work with respected professionals, and stay focused on quality and eye appeal. Most importantly, enjoy the thrill of the chase and the pride of ownership.
Just beware: once you catch "gold fever," you may never view pocket change the same way again!
Sources and Further Reading
- Akers, David. United States Gold Coins: An Analysis of Auction Records, Volume IV, Gold Dollars 1849-1889. Paramount Publications, 1975.
- Bowers, Q. David. A Guide Book of United States Type Coins, 3rd Edition. Whitman Publishing, 2016.
- Breen, Walter. Walter Breen‘s Complete Encyclopedia of U.S. and Colonial Coins. Doubleday, 1988.
- PCGS CoinFacts. "Gold Dollars (1849-1889)." Accessed June 10, 2023. https://www.pcgs.com/coinfacts/category/gold-dollars/7
- Winter, Douglas. Gold Coins of the Charlotte Mint: 1838-1861. DWN Publishing, 2008.
- Winter, Douglas. Gold Coins of the Dahlonega Mint: 1838-1861. DWN Publishing, 1997.
