Skip to content

WD Red vs Blue: Which Hard Drive Should You Buy?

Western Digital‘s WD Red and WD Blue hard drives target two very different use cases – WD Red for network attached storage (NAS) and RAID systems, and WD Blue for general purpose computing. In this 2500+ word guide, we‘ll dig into the key similarities and differences to help you decide which is the right fit for your needs.

Intended Use Cases: WD Red for NAS, WD Blue for Everyday Computing

The WD Red lineup is purpose-built for home and small business NAS and RAID applications requiring high reliability and 24/7 operation. These drives are optimized for compatibility and sustained performance in multi-drive systems.

Conversely, WD Blue drives are designed for mainstream PCs, laptops, and all-purpose computing. They balance performance and affordability for things like storing your personal media library, system backups, gaming, or running common productivity software.

So if you‘re looking to add storage to an existing or new NAS, WD Red is the way to go. But if you just want an inexpensive way to add capacity to your desktop, WD Blue is likely the better choice.

Storage Capacities Span a Wide Range

Both product families offer a range of capacities to choose from.

WD Red drives are currently available from 2TB up to 6TB. Having drives in various sizes gives you flexibility in how you configure your array. And the largest 6TB model provides ample storage for most small businesses to store things like documents, backups, shared media files.

WD Blue drives start at just 500GB, but scale all the way up to 8TB. The smaller 500GB and 1TB sizes target entry-level users on tight budgets. While the high capacity 6TB+ models compete directly with WD Red for storage-hungry applications.

No matter which you choose, you likely can find a drive size to suit your needs. But higher capacity drives generally come with better performance too…

Performance and Speeds: A Close Race

When comparing benchmark performance numbers, WD Red and WD Blue trade blows and go back and forth:

Transfer Speed

  • WD Red: 180 MB/s
  • WD Blue: 150 MB/s

Disk Speed (RPM)

  • WD Red: 5400 RPM
  • WD Blue: 7200 RPM

Cache Size

  • WD Red: 256 MB
  • WD Blue: 32-256MB

The Red has a faster transfer rate but spins more slowly. While the Blue spins quicker but has slightly slower data transfers.

Ultimately, both deliver speedy performance for their intended applications. And other factors like the SSD cache on your NAS device or amount of RAM in your desktop can minimize any differences between these drives.

Pricing and Value Comparison

In terms of cost, WD Blue generally has an advantage. With street prices starting under $50 for some models. While equivalent WD Reds sell for 10-15% more.

However, the premium paid for WD Red gets you enhanced reliability features given the operating conditions drives face living inside a NAS or RAID enclosure. Specifically, the NASware firmware optimizes WD Reds for multi-user environments by reducing vibration and smoothly handling heavy workloads.

And over a 3-5 year lifespan, the marginal upfront cost difference becomes less and less significant. Paying an extra $15 for peace of mind and advanced technology can be worth it if you plan to rely heavily on your NAS.

Ideal Uses for Each Drive

WD Red

WD Red really shines in home and small business NAS appliances running 24/7. It‘s optimized for constant operation and the vibrations inherent in multi-drive chassis. Red also supports advanced RAID configurations like RAID 5/6 for added data protection.

WD Blue

For everyday desktop computing, WD Blue is a workhorse. Its versatility across different PC configurations and environments make it a solid choice for basic storage needs. It balances performance, capacity, and value in a single drive.

Brief History of WD Red and WD Blue

Western Digital entered the consumber-grade NAS market in 2012 with the launch of WD Red. Early capacity points focused on 2TB to 4TB models. Over the years, they‘ve refined the technology and scaled up to 6TB. We will likely see 8TB+ WD Reds hit the market in coming years as NAS devices continue gaining popularity.

The WD Blue lineage traces back further as a evolution of their former WD Caviar desktop hard drives. In 2016, WD combined its Green low-power drives into the Blue brand to simplify choices. Now WD Blue drives cover everything from entry-level portable drives up to high capacity models pushing the limits of HDD technology.

Key Factors When Deciding Between WD Red vs Blue

  • Price – WD Blue generally cheaper across comparable capacities
  • Performance – Roughly equal, with slight tradeoffs in RPM vs transfer speed
  • Reliability – WD Red built for 24/7 NAS workload, includes vibration protection
  • Capacity – WD Blue scales higher currently (8TB max), WD Red tops out at 6TB
  • Compatibility – WD Red optimized for NAS and RAID configurations

Which is Better for You?

For home or small business NAS applications, the WD Red is worth the small premium over desktop HDDs. It‘s designed specifically for always-on operation and multi-drive systems common in networked storage and RAID setups.

But for general computing uses like storing your personal media library or backups, WD Blue offers reliable performance at budget-friendly pricing. Its versatility across different desktop configurations and environments make it my top choice for basic storage needs.

In the end, aligning your use case to the right hard drive provides the best long term value and peace of mind. Let your goals and workload drive the decision rather than small spec differences between models.

I hope this detailed comparison between WD‘s Red and Blue product families helps simplify your buying decision. Let me know in the comments if you have any other questions!