As a professional numismatist and lifelong collector of vintage U.S. proof coinage, I‘ve had the privilege of handling many exceptional classic proof sets over the years. Yet one issue never fails to quicken my pulse when I lift the lid on that small, unassuming cardboard box and glimpse the mirror-like surfaces within – the 1936 proof set.
The 1936 proof set represents a watershed moment in 20th century U.S. numismatics as the first complete set of proof coins issued by the United States Mint since 1916. With a record-low mintage and a key first-year status, it has become one of the most coveted issues among proof set collectors.
In this comprehensive guide, I‘ll share my insights on the history, rarity, and long-term value potential of this numismatic icon. We‘ll go beyond the raw price data to explore the set‘s unique story and offer expert tips for collectors seeking to add a 1936 proof set to their holdings.
Whether you‘re a seasoned proof set aficionado or a newcomer to the vintage coin market, read on to deepen your knowledge and appreciation of one of the most important U.S. proof sets ever issued.
The Proof Set Tradition: 1858-1916
To fully understand the significance of the 1936 proof set, we need to start with some historical context. Proof coinage has a long and storied history at the U.S. Mint, dating back to the 1810s when special presentation strikes were first made for dignitaries and VIPs.
However, it wasn‘t until 1858 that the Mint began issuing proof coins on a wider basis to collectors. That year saw the release of the first commercially available proof sets in the U.S., featuring the copper-nickel cent, silver half dime, dime, quarter, and half dollar.
The late 19th century was the heyday of classic proof set production, with many legendary issues like the 1873 "closed 3" set and the 1895 Morgan dollar emerging from this era. Mintages rose from the low hundreds in the 1860s to a peak of around 1,200 by the early 1900s.
A few key events disrupted the continuity of proof coinage in the early 20th century:
- In 1906, the Mint discontinued regular proof production of denominations higher than the cent due to dwindling collector interest and the glut of proof gold coins in government vaults. Proofs would only be struck in gold on a case-by-case basis, making many issues from 1906-1915 immensely rare.
- U.S. entry into World War I in 1917 forced the Mint to focus its resources on circulating coinage and war medals, suspending proof production altogether.
After the war, the Mint was slow to restart proof coinage, striking only a small number of individual coins throughout the 1920s and early 1930s. Collector interest in current issues was at a low ebb during the depths of the Great Depression, giving the Mint little incentive to resume full-scale proof sets.
It would take a visionary Mint Director and a resurgence in the coin market to bring the proof set tradition back to life in 1936.
The Renaissance of 1936
The year 1936 marked a turning point in the fortunes of the U.S. coin collecting community. The worst years of the Great Depression were finally fading into the rearview mirror, and Americans were starting to have disposable income again for hobbies and discretionary purchases.
Coin collecting had long been one of the nation‘s most popular pastimes, with a vibrant community of collectors and dealers gathered under the umbrella of the American Numismatic Association (founded 1891). As the U.S. economy began its recovery in the mid-1930s, the coin market started to heat up again, with strong prices realized for classic rarities and an influx of new collectors.
U.S. Mint Director Nellie Tayloe Ross sensed an opportunity in this revived collector interest. A trailblazing figure as the first woman to hold the office, Ross aimed to raise the Mint‘s public profile and promote coin collecting as a wholesome educational pursuit.
Resuming proof coinage after a 20-year hiatus was one of Ross‘s signature initiatives. In a 1936 press release announcing the new proof sets, she stated:
"There has been a considerable demand in recent years from coin collectors for specimen sets of the current coin of the realm […] I believe that a limited number of sets will be eagerly taken up by that portion of the public interested in this subject."
Ross‘s gambit paid off, as collectors quickly snapped up the 3,837 proof sets issued in 1936, marking a new era in U.S. numismatics. Priced at $1.89 per set (around $40 today), the 1936 proof set was a luxury purchase for most collectors during the Depression. But it signaled a vote of confidence in the enduring appeal of numismatics.
Little could Ross and the Mint have known in 1936 just how sought-after those first modern proof sets would eventually become. Nor could the collectors who purchased them have imagined the dizzying heights to which the coin market would soar in the decades to come.
The 1936 Proof Set by the Numbers
The 1936 proof set‘s key distinguishing features are:
- First modern U.S. proof set issued after a 20-year hiatus in set production
- Record-low mintage of 3,837 sets, the lowest for any U.S. proof set of the 20th century
- Transition from matte/satin to brilliant mirror finish partway through the production run
The set contained five denominations, all struck at the Philadelphia Mint and bearing no mint marks. The Mint‘s packaging for these first modern proof sets was simple and utilitarian, consisting of a cardboard box with a separate lid and die-cut holes to hold the coins. Delicate tissue paper was used to separate the coins from each other and protect the surfaces.
Here are the specifications for each coin in the set:
| Denomination | Composition | Weight | Diameter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cent | Bronze | 3.11 grams | 19 mm |
| Nickel | 75% Cu, 25% Ni | 5.00 grams | 21.2 mm |
| Dime | 90% Ag, 10% Cu | 2.50 grams | 17.9 mm |
| Quarter | 90% Ag, 10% Cu | 6.25 grams | 24.3 mm |
| Half Dollar | 90% Ag, 10% Cu | 12.50 grams | 30.6 mm |
Of the 3,837 total sets minted, an estimated 2,000 to 2,500 were of the matte/satin finish.
The reason for the switch to brilliant finish partway through 1936 is not entirely clear from Mint records, but most numismatic historians believe it was in response to collector dissatisfaction with the satin coins, which many felt looked too similar to regular circulation strikes. The brilliant mirror finish became the new standard for all later proof issues.
Today, the satin finish 1936 proof sets are prized for their first-year status and unique place in proof set history. They represent around 60% of the original mintage but only a small fraction of surviving sets due to the delicacy of the finish.
Condition Census and Survival Estimates
As of 2023, PCGS CoinFacts estimates that around 1,750 of the original 3,837 proof sets have survived intact, with perhaps another 750 or so extant as individual coins that have been broken out of the original sets over the years.
These are the PCGS population figures for the 1936 proof set coins in each grade:
| Grade | Cent | Nickel | Dime | Quarter | Half Dollar |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PR-64 | 181 | 167 | 186 | 190 | 170 |
| PR-65 | 301 | 346 | 361 | 358 | 293 |
| PR-66 | 249 | 219 | 224 | 147 | 131 |
| PR-67 | 44 | 47 | 51 | 54 | 40 |
| PR-68 | 5 | 8 | 5 | 2 | 2 |
NGC‘s census data shows similar relative populations by grade.
A few important things to note:
- PCGS and NGC will attribute the finish on brilliant coins as "Brilliant" but the finish for satin coins is not always specified on the label
- Satin finish coins generally grade lower than brilliant ones due to their more delicate surfaces
- Over 95% of all 1936 proof sets certified by PCGS and NGC grade between PR-64 and PR-66
- Gems grading PR-67 or PR-68 are exceedingly rare, usually with populations in just the single or double digits for each coin
- No 1936 proof coin has ever graded PR-69 or PR-70 at either service; a "perfect" set may not exist
Market Analysis and Auction Prices
The 1936 proof set has been one of the best-performing issues in the rare coin market over the past few decades, with prices appreciating steadily as the set has become a must-have trophy for top-end proof set collectors.
Looking at auction records from 2000 to the present, we can track the trajectory of the 1936 proof set across various grade levels:
-
In 2000, mid-range PR-64 to PR-65 sets routinely sold for $2,000 to $3,000. Today, those same sets bring $8,000 to $12,000, a 4X to 5X increase.
-
In 2010, a high-end PR-66 set with original box but not attributed as satin was a $10,000 coin. In 2022, a virtually identical set commanded over $28,000.
-
Back in 1996, a satin finish 1936 set graded PR-65 by PCGS realized $16,500, then a record price. In 2022, a similar PCGS PR-65 set with satin finish sold for over $54,000, more than tripling in value after 26 years.
The biggest price movers have been sets with original packaging and superb-gem grades. In 2014, Heritage Auctions sold a brilliant finish set graded PR-67 by NGC with original box and documentation for $23,500. Fast forward to 2022 and a comparably graded set took $49,200.
The stratospheric prices are reserved for the finest-known satin finish sets. Consider these data points:
- A satin finish 1936 set graded PCGS PR-66 with original box sold for $43,475 in 2011.
- In 2017, a satin PCGS PR-66 set with a CAC sticker realized $70,500.
- That record was broken again in 2021 by the famous Eliasberg satin set graded PCGS PR-67 at $85,187.
So what does the future hold for the 1936 proof set? While short-term fluctuations are impossible to predict, the set has a number of factors working in its favor as a long-term store of value:
-
Extremely low original mintage with perhaps 40% of sets lost or broken up over time
-
Increasing pressure on supply from both proof set specialists and advanced type set collectors seeking finest-known examples of each denomination
-
The 1936 set‘s unassailable first-year status as the key to a complete 20th/21st century U.S. proof set collection
-
Crossover appeal to Registry Set collectors competing to assemble the all-time finest sets in each category
-
Important historical significance as the first proof coins of the modern era and the start of an enduring Mint tradition
Gem satin finish sets may have the greatest upside potential as the market continues to awaken to their unique status and rarity. Look for these to set new price records if any emerge from long-held collections in the coming years.
The one headwind for future price appreciation may be sheer affordability. A world-class 1936 proof set has already priced itself out of many collector budgets.
Collecting Tips and Conclusions
For collectors ready to take the plunge into the deep end of the proof set market, here are some expert tips for cherrypicking quality and avoiding problem coins:
-
Buy the set, not individual coins. A complete original set will always command a premium over one assembled from different sources.
-
Focus on eye appeal. The technical grade is important but the ultimate value lies in a coin‘s visual impact. Look for exceptional contrast between mirrors and devices, minimal hairlines, and a complete absence of spotting or milky haze.
-
Understand the finish. A top-quality brilliant 1936 set should have deeply reflective mirrors and razor-sharp strikes with no softness on the high points. Satin finish coins will display fine die polish lines in the fields when viewed under magnification. Some satin sets also come with one or two brilliant finish coins.
-
Beware damage and alterations. Proof surface hairlines are common and do not always show in photos. Dipped or conserved coins may have unnatural color or diminished luster. Inspect any raw sets in person if possible.
-
Demand original packaging. Unless you are buying a graded set, the presence of the original card box and packing materials is essential to confirming originality and commanding a maximum price.
-
Work with trusted dealers. The market for classic proof sets has its share of dangers in the form of counterfeits, doctored coins, and overgraded pieces. Buy only from reputable dealers who offer a lifetime guarantee of authenticity.
The 1936 proof set will always be desirable as the first of its kind and an enduring numismatic classic. For collectors with the budget and patience to pursue a world-class set, it offers immense pride of ownership and long-term value potential.
Yet with prices starting at over $10,000 for a set of exceptional quality, it is not for the faint of heart. As the number of collectors at the high end of the market grows, top-quality 1936 proof sets may well prove to be a "recession-proof" slice of numismatic history.
Whether you are assembling a complete 20th century type set, specializing in proof coinage, or simply drawn to the most prized issues of the modern era, the 1936 proof set deserves a place of consideration in your collecting goals. Its story has been nearly a century in the making – and the most exciting chapters may be yet to come.
