For many coin collectors, there‘s nothing more exciting than discovering a rare and valuable minting error. When the U.S. Mint makes a mistake during the coin production process, the resulting error coins become some of the most sought-after treasures in numismatics.
Minting errors can range from subtle die cracks to dramatic double strikes, off-center strikes, and coins struck on the wrong planchet. The most dramatic and rare errors are also the most valuable, with some error coins selling for tens of thousands of dollars at auction.
One of the most popular modern coin series for error collectors is the 50 State Quarters program. Issued by the U.S. Mint from 1999 through 2009, this 10-year series includes a unique reverse design for each of the 50 states. The series was later followed by a one-year program with six additional coins honoring Washington D.C. and the U.S. territories.
In this guide, we‘ll take an in-depth look at the rarest and most valuable state quarter errors known to the collecting community. We‘ll discuss how these error coins are created, how to identify them, and what they‘re worth on the open market. Whether you‘re an experienced error coin collector or just learning about this fascinating segment of the hobby, you won‘t want to miss this definitive reference on state quarter errors.
50 State Quarters Program Overview
Before we dive into the most valuable state quarter errors, let‘s start with an overview of the 50 State Quarters program itself. In 1997, Congress passed the United States Commemorative Coin Program Act, which authorized the U.S. Mint to issue a series of circulating commemorative quarters honoring each of the 50 states.
The program began in 1999 and continued at a rate of five new state designs per year until the final coins were released in 2009. Each state was honored in the order that it ratified the Constitution or was admitted into the Union. Here‘s a year-by-year breakdown:
1999: Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Georgia, Connecticut
2000: Massachusetts, Maryland, South Carolina, New Hampshire, Virginia
2001: New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Vermont, Kentucky
2002: Tennessee, Ohio, Louisiana, Indiana, Mississippi
2003: Illinois, Alabama, Maine, Missouri, Arkansas
2004: Michigan, Florida, Texas, Iowa, Wisconsin
2005: California, Minnesota, Oregon, Kansas, West Virginia
2006: Nevada, Nebraska, Colorado, North Dakota, South Dakota
2007: Montana, Washington, Idaho, Wyoming, Utah
2008: Oklahoma, New Mexico, Arizona, Alaska, Hawaii
2009: District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa, U.S. Virgin Islands, Northern Mariana Islands
Each coin in the series maintained the standard Washington Quarter obverse design, with some slight modifications. The reverse featured a unique design emblematic of each honored state or territory, as chosen by the state‘s governor.
With over 34 billion coins produced in total, the 50 State Quarters program was the most popular commemorative coin program in U.S. Mint history. At the peak of the collecting craze, over 100 million Americans were collecting these coins from pocket change.
Types of State Quarter Errors
With such an extensive minting, it‘s no surprise that many state quarter errors were also created during the series run. Minting errors can occur at any stage of the coin production process, and even with modern minting technology, it‘s inevitable that some error coins will escape detection and enter circulation.
In general, there are three main categories of minting errors: planchet errors, die errors, and strike errors. Here‘s an overview of each type with examples specific to the state quarters series:
Planchet Errors
A planchet is the blank metal disc that a coin is struck on. Planchet errors occur when there is a problem with the planchet itself, either before or during the striking process.
Some of the most common planchet errors include:
- Clipped planchets
- Elliptical or incomplete planchets
- Wrong metal or off-composition planchets
- Defective or contaminated planchets
One dramatic example of a state quarter planchet error is the 1999 Delaware quarter struck on an experimental silver-colored planchet. This transitional error was created when the Mint used leftover experimental planchets (likely from the Susan B. Anthony dollar) in a state quarter press. Only a few examples are known and they have sold for over $7,000 at auction.
Die Errors
A die is the hardened metal stamp used to impart the design onto the coin. Die errors occur when there is a problem with the die itself, either from damage, excessive wear, or mistakes made during die production.
Some of the most common die errors include:
- Die cracks, chips, or breaks
- Die cuds (raised blobs of metal attached to the rim)
- Double die errors (design details appear doubled)
- Misaligned or rotated dies
One of the most famous state quarter die errors is the "Extra Leaf" variety on the 2004 Wisconsin quarter. This error was created when a small gouge near the left corn leaf was misinterpreted as an extra leaf. Later die states even show this extra leaf filled in, creating the appearance of a small extra leaf pointing upwards. High grade examples of the Extra Leaf error have sold for over $1,500.
Strike Errors
Strike errors occur when something goes wrong during the actual minting process as the coin is being struck. This could be due to human error, machine malfunctions, or debris interfering with the striking dies.
Some of the most common and dramatic strike errors include:
- Off-center strikes
- Double or multiple strikes
- Broadstrikes (coin struck without a collar)
- Brockages (incuse mirror image of the design)
One remarkable state quarter strike error is a 2000-P South Carolina quarter double struck on a Sacagawea dollar planchet. This dramatic error creates a 25-cent/dollar denomination mule and is unique in the series. The one known example sold for $35,000 in a 2013 auction.
Most Valuable State Quarter Errors
Now that we‘ve covered the types of errors that can be found on state quarters, let‘s look at some of the most valuable examples. The following table lists 25 of the rarest and most sought-after state quarter errors, along with their key details and current market values.
Note that error coin values can fluctuate significantly based on the specific coin‘s condition, visual appeal, and overall market demand. The prices listed here are based on recent auction results and dealer listings, but should be considered approximate rather than definitive.
[TABLE]How Error Coin Values Are Determined
You may be wondering how coin experts determine the value of rare error coins like these state quarters. While each error coin is unique, there are some key factors that influence their numismatic value:
Rarity: In general, the fewer examples of the error that are known, the more valuable those coins will be. Unique error coins (meaning no other examples have been found) are the most desirable.
Visual Appeal: Error coins that are dramatic and obvious to the naked eye tend to be more valuable than coins with subtle errors. Collectors gravitate towards coins with eye-catching visual features.
Popularity: Certain error types are more popular with collectors than others, and this demand influences the market value. Currently, off-center strikes, double strikes, and striking errors on the wrong planchet are very much in vogue.
Mint and Grade: As with non-error coins, the condition and origin of the coin matters to value. Error coins from the Philadelphia (no mint mark) and Denver (D) mints are generally more desirable than San Francisco (S) examples. Higher numerical grades are also correlated with higher prices.
Documentation: Error coins that have been authenticated, graded and encapsulated by a major third-party grading service like PCGS or NGC tend to have a premium over "raw" examples. Certification gives buyers confidence in the coin‘s authenticity and grade.
While all of these factors work together to determine an error coin‘s fair market value, it ultimately comes down to what an individual buyer is willing to pay. At major auctions, it only takes two passionate collectors to drive the price of a rare error coin well beyond expectations.
Buying and Selling State Quarter Errors
If reading this guide has inspired you to start your own collection of state quarter errors, you may be wondering where to buy and sell these rare coins. As with any valuable collectible, it‘s important to work with reputable dealers and auction houses to ensure you are getting authentic coins at fair market prices.
Some of the best places to buy error coins online include:
- Heritage Auctions (coins.HA.com)
- GreatCollections Coin Auctions (greatcollections.com)
- David Lawrence Rare Coins (davidlawrence.com)
- APMEX (apmex.com)
- Mint Errors (minterrornews.com)
Before buying a coin, make sure you understand the terms of sale, including the return policy and any buyer‘s premiums that will be added to the total price. Be wary of buying rare coins on eBay unless the seller has a stellar reputation in the numismatic community.
When it comes time to sell your state quarter errors, you‘ll generally get the best prices by consigning your coins to a major auction house. Alternatively, you can sell directly to a coin dealer or list them on online marketplaces like eBay. Just be sure to disclose any problems with the coin and take clear photos that accurately represent its appearance.
FAQs About State Quarter Errors
We‘ll wrap up this guide by answering some of the most frequently asked questions about state quarter errors. If you still have questions after reading this article, please leave a comment below and I‘ll do my best to help!
Q: How do I know if my state quarter is an error coin?
A: The best way to determine if you have a genuine error coin is to compare it to a normal example of the same issue. Look for differences in the design, lettering, or overall shape of the coin. You can also try weighing the coin to check if it‘s the correct weight for a quarter. If you suspect you have found an error, consider submitting it to a grading service like PCGS or NGC for authentication.
Q: Are all state quarter errors valuable?
A: No, not all state quarter errors are valuable. In fact, some common mistakes like slightly misaligned dies or incomplete strikes are considered "trivial" mint errors and have little to no premium over face value. The most valuable errors are dramatic, rare, and in high grade.
Q: What‘s the most valuable state quarter error ever found?
A: The undisputed king of state quarter errors is the unique 2000-P South Carolina quarter/Sacagawea dollar double denomination mule. Struck on a dollar coin planchet and showing a clear double strike, this coin sold for $35,000 in a 2013 Heritage auction.
Q: Can state quarter errors still be found in circulation?
A: While it‘s unlikely you‘ll find a major state quarter error in your pocket change 15-20 years after the series ended, it‘s not impossible! Many collectors still enjoy searching rolls of bank-wrapped quarters just in case a new error is discovered. You never know when you might get lucky.
Q: What should I do if I find a state quarter error?
A: If you believe you‘ve found a genuine state quarter error, the first step is to have it authenticated by a reputable third-party grading service. Companies like PCGS, NGC, ANACS and ICG will examine your coin, grade its condition, and encapsulate it in a labeled holder for a modest fee. Once your coin has been authenticated, you can either add it to your personal collection or consign it to an auction house to determine its market value.
The Thrill of the Hunt
Collecting state quarter errors is a fun and challenging pursuit that attracts thousands of enthusiasts worldwide. The thrill of discovering a rare and valuable error coin is hard to beat!
While the state quarters series may have ended in 2009, collectors are still finding new errors and varieties to this day. By studying the coins in your collection and learning to spot key diagnostics, you too could make the next big find.
I hope you‘ve enjoyed this in-depth guide to the most valuable state quarter errors. Please let me know in the comments what other types of error coins you‘d like to learn about. In the meantime, I wish you the best of luck in your collecting adventures!
){kind=link}