Google and Bing have been battling it out in the search engine space for over a decade now. With Google controlling over 90% of the market, it‘s easy to think this is a one-sided fight. However, Bing has slowly and steadily been improving its search technology and features.
In this in-depth comparison guide, we‘ll look at the key differences between Google and Bing in 2023 to help you decide which search engine is better for your needs.
A Brief History of Google and Bing
To understand where these search giants are today, let‘s first look at how they started and evolved over the years.
The Rise of Google
Google traces its origins back to 1996 when Larry Page and Sergey Brin met at Stanford University. They began collaborating on a search engine called Backrub that analyzed the backlinks pointing to websites to rank results.
After renaming it to Google, the search engine officially launched in 1998 with the goal of organizing the world‘s information. While other search engines at the time focused on keywords, Google relied on its PageRank algorithm to deliver more relevant results.
Over the next decade, Google rapidly grew in popularity thanks to its clean interface, speed, and accuracy. It became the default search engine across browsers like Firefox and Safari. Google also made strategic acquisitions such as YouTube in 2006 and DoubleClick in 2007 to expand into video and advertising.
By 2010, Google controlled nearly 90% of the search market, cementing its place as the leader. It has maintained that firm lead ever since but has faced increased scrutiny around privacy and antitrust violations.
The Launch of Bing
Microsoft entered the search engine market in 1998 with MSN Search. It was rebranded as Live Search in 2006 before becoming Bing in 2009.
The "Bing" name came from the concept of a "bing" lightbulb moment. Microsoft wanted the search engine to provide meaningful insights to users.
Over the years, Bing has enhanced its search capabilities with features like quick answers and visual search. It has also focused on delivering a more visually appealing interface with daily background images.
However, Bing has struggled to chip away at Google‘s market share. As of 2022, it sits around 7% globally. Microsoft has looked to integrate Bing deeper into its products like Windows and Edge to drive more usage.
With AI chatbots like ChatGPT gaining popularity, both Google and Bing are looking to infuse more conversational AI into search. This could lead to a shift in market dynamics.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Here is an overview of how Google and Bing stack up across some key metrics:
| Metric | Bing | |
|---|---|---|
| Global market share | 92% | 7% |
| Searches per day | Over 5 billion | Estimated 1.2 billion |
| Available languages | 150+ | 130+ |
| Launch year | 1998 | 2009 |
| Founders | Larry Page and Sergey Brin | Microsoft |
| Revenue source | Advertising | Advertising |
Both search engines offer similar core capabilities like web, image, video, and news search. But they differ significantly when it comes to market adoption.
Google sees over 5 billion searches per day globally compared to around 1.2 billion for Bing. This massive search volume allows Google to better understand user intent and optimize results.
Next, let‘s dive deeper into some of the key differences between the two search engine giants.
Index Size and Crawling Capabilities
One major search engine advantage Google has over Bing is its immense index size.
Google claims to have indexed over 130 trillion web pages. The exact size of Bing‘s index is unknown, but most estimates peg it at 50-70 billion pages.
Google‘s lead in this area allows it to find more obscure long-tail queries and deliver more comprehensive results across languages and regions. It has more data to understand real user behavior and satisfaction with results.
Google also benefits from having more crawl budget, which is the capacity for how many pages a search engine can scan and analyze. With over 3500+ developers, Google is better equipped to discover new or updated content faster.
Bing‘s smaller index is more prone to thin or missing results for unique queries. But Microsoft is working to improve Bing‘s crawling capabilities through techniques like forcing pages to be re-crawled regularly.
Advertising Reach and Capabilities
Given Google‘s tremendous scale, it‘s no surprise that it also dominates the search advertising space. Google captured over 73% of the US search ad market in 2022, compared to under 4% for Microsoft Advertising (formerly Bing Ads).
Google simply has vastly more demand from advertisers looking to get their products and services in front of users during the critical path to purchase. This funds continual improvements to Google‘s ad targeting, formats, and performance reporting capabilities.
Bing Ads does offer a few unique features like broad match keywords and API access. But Google Ads tends to have more robust options for managing large accounts, automating campaigns, and analyzing granular metrics. The gap in reach and ROI potential remains substantial currently.
Personalization and Privacy
Google and Bing take slightly different approaches when it comes to personalization and user privacy controls.
Being logged into your Google account enables greater personalization of search results based on your search history, location, and other profile data. Google states this helps provide more relevant results.
However, it has received criticism over privacy implications and filter bubbles. Users have limited visibility or control into how their personal data might influence search results.
Bing also personalizes results to a degree when logged in but states it is focused on privacy. Microsoft has actively promoted Bing as the search engine with less user tracking.
Bing does not store IP addresses or unique identifiers of signed out users. Location and search history data is also automatically deleted after 6 months for those with Microsoft accounts.
So while Google offers deeper personalization, Bing aims to deliver a more anonymous and transparent search experience.
Local Search Capabilities
Location-based search is vital for users looking for nearby businesses or services. Both Bing and Google integrate extensive business listings and local results into their search platforms.
Google provides a "maps" carousel for proximity-based searches along with Knowledge Panels for businesses. Users can easily search for a type of business near them and see key information like opening hours and locations.
Bing similarly displays location-sorted business results along with aggregated review data from sites like Yelp. One advantage Bing has is offering multi-location businesses more control over local listing consistency through Bing Places for Business.
Google‘s local search capabilities are likely more comprehensive given its scale. But Bing does enable deeper management of location data for brands.
Shopping and Commerce Experience
Product search is another major search engine battleground as users increasingly start their shopping journeys online.
Google Shopping ties in tightly with merchant feeds and Google Ads. Retailers can promote products in dedicated Shopping ads at the top of Google‘s results. Users also see extract product information like pricing and stock status.
Bing Shopping has fewer merchant partnerships and product listings at this stage. But it provides universal product metadata extraction from any site. Bing also incorporates more visual cues like star ratings aggregated from merchant sites.
For researching and evaluating products, most shopping-focused users still gravitate towards Google. But Bing delivers a cleaner visual commerce experience.
As voice shopping gains adoption through smart assistants, the reach of Google Assistant versus Microsoft Cortana may also impact commerce behaviors.
Video Search and Viewing
YouTube has made Google the dominant player when it comes to searching for and watching videos online. YouTube sees over 2 billion monthly logged-in users.
Google displays YouTube video results prominently within its search platform. Users can easily preview top videos on a topic and pivot to YouTube proper for suggested viewing.
In contrast, Bing has no affiliated video property. While it does show video carousels, clicking these simply links out to other sites like YouTube or Vimeo.
Bing also misses the robust transcriptions, captions, and metadata Google obtains from YouTube to improve video discovery. Identifying relevant clips is faster with Google’s knowledge of YouTube’s content graph.
Clearly if searching for instructional videos or developing video content strategies, Google and YouTube should be the first stop.
Interface Design and Usability
Interface design plays a big role in the user experience of a search engine. There are some distinct philosophies between Google and Bing’s approaches.
Google opts for a minimalist interface prioritizing the search box and 10 blue links. The focus is entirely on the results with few distracting elements. The Google logo acts as the only clickable element to return back home.
Bing has more dynamic elements like the daily background image, sidebar news, and multiple homepage modules. There is greater visual prominence on the Bing name and navigation.
In terms of usability, Google’s spartan design allows slightly faster search input. But Bing’s visual cues and context around queries help guide exploration and discovery.
The choice comes down to either no-frills utility with Google or richer contextual searching through Bing. Both have merits depending on user preferences.
Innovative Search Features
Google and Bing are continually rolling out new pilot features to test out advanced search concepts. Here are some examples of innovations where each has been trying to gain an edge:
Google Lens – Visual search tool that lets you search what you see through your phone camera. Helps identify objects, locations, plants, animals, and text snippets. Makes searching the physical world intuitive.
Bing Visual Search – Find visually similar images and products by uploading an image or choosing visual filters. Great for discovering fashion, furniture, and art inspiration.
Google Collections – Curation feature that lets you save, organize, and export searches and results into shareable collections. Handy for research and travel planning.
Bing Chat – Conversational AI that brings ChatGPT-like capabilities into the search box for simplified queries, explanations, and recommendations. More natural way to interact with search.
Google Multisearch – Allows combined image and text queries through Google Lens camera and search bar. Helps find something using both an image and descriptive keywords.
Bing Maps Immersive View – Fully-modeled 3D view of cities using AI data enrichment. Provides more engaging spatial context for navigating and exploring.
Both search engines are pushing boundaries into AI-assisted discovery that goes beyond the standard “10 blue links”. It will be exciting to see these innovations develop and expand over time.
Privacy and Data Collection
Privacy has become an increasingly prominent concern for tech platforms including search engines. Google and Bing take slightly divergent approaches here.
Google logs and associates vast amounts of personal usage data across products to target ads and personalize the experience. Location, search history, and other sensitive data can be stored indefinitely if you stay logged into your Google account.
In contrast, Bing aims for a more privacy-centric model aligned with European GDPR standards. Microsoft states it does not store unique identifiers for anonymous Bing visitors. Personal data is also automatically deleted after 6 months if you are logged out or inactive.
For those want greater visibility into how their information is being tracked and used, Bing provides more transparency and controls around data collection. Google gives users the option to pause tracking but less insight.
If you are comfortable exchanging some privacy for more personalized results, Google certainly delivers. But Bing is making a conscious effort to enable anonymous search with data safeguards.
Advertising and Content Policies
Advertising fuels the business models behind leading search engines. But it has also created controversies around which ads are allowed alongside information seeking behaviors.
Google has faced scrutiny for enabling and profiting from ads around questionable products, politics, or content. Despite recent policy updates, critics argue Google does not do enough to restrict ads on sensitive or misleading topics.
Microsoft has looked to differentiate Bing by taking a stronger stance limiting ads for things like arms, election misinformation, and cryptocurrencies. The focus is on reducing harmful or exploitative advertising.
Both search engines use a combination of automated and human reviews. But Bing’s advertising content policies tend to be more conservative overall. Brand safety is higher on Bing, although ad targeting capabilities are more limited.
Which Search Engine is Better Overall?
With this comprehensive feature comparison in mind, which search engine comes out on top in 2023? Here are a few key considerations:
-
Google wins on scale and comprehensive results – With over 130 trillion indexed pages and 5 billion daily searches, Google can surface long-tail, fresh, and localized content more reliably. It’s unrivaled for obscure queries.
-
Bing delivers a more visually engaging experience – From the daily images to integrated maps and rich content cards, Bing provides greater aesthetic and contextual appeal during discovery.
-
Google dominates search advertising – The vastly superior reach and ad platform capabilities make Google the only choice for brands investing in search ads currently.
-
Bing prioritizes transparency and privacy – From anonymized data practices to restricted ad policies, Bing offers a search experience with fewer invasive tracking and targeting elements relative to Google.
-
Google has the edge in commerce and video – With Google Shopping and YouTube tightly integrated, Google better serves product-focused and video-centric searching scenarios.
Overall, Google remains the powerhouse search leader based on market share, capabilities, and user habit. It will take time for Bing to close core gaps like index depth, personalization accuracy, and advertising reach.
However, Bing has carved out differentiated strengths around visual presentation, local results, and privacy. The infusion of ChatGPT-level conversational AI into Bing also poses an intriguing challenge to Google’s traditional search paradigm.
For most everyday needs, Google certainly delivers satisfactory results efficiently. But it’s worth occasionally comparing search experiences and capabilities between the two.
Bing’s evolution shows healthy competition can spur search innovation on both sides – even if market dominance remains lopsided currently. As needs around privacy, e-commerce, or AI grow, we may see more targeted situations where Bing holds appeal over Google for some consumers.